240 INSTITUTES OF THE [bOOK II.
while the law commands, and man acts from his own strength
:
but when the Spirit assists, and the human will obeys, not as
being free, but as liberated by God. And he briefly assigns
the cause of all this, when, in another place, he tells us, that
man at his creation received great strength of free will, bui
lost It by sin. Therefore, having shown that free will is the
result of grace, he sharply inveighs against those who arrogate
it to themselves without grace. "How, then," says he, " do
miserable men dare to be proud of free will, before they are
liberated, or of their own strength, if they have been liberated ? "
Nor do they consider that the term free loill signifies liberty.
But '• where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty." (w) If,
therefore, they are the slaves of sin, why do they boast of free
will ? " For of whom a man is overcome, of the same is he
brought in bondage." (o) But if they have been liberated,
why do they boast as of their own work ? Are they so much
at liberty as to refuse to be the servants of him who says,
"Without me ye can do nothing"? (^) Besides, in another
place, also, he seems to discountenance the use of that expres-
sion, when he says that the will is free, but not liberated ; free
from righteousness, enslaved to sin. This sentiment he also
repeats and applies in another place, where he maintains that
man is not free from righteousness, but by the choice of his
will, and that he is not made free from sin, but by the grace
of the Saviour. He who declares that human liberty is no-
thing but an emancipation or manumission from righteousness,
evidently exposes it to ridicule as an unmeaning term. There-
fore, if any man allows himself the use of this term without
any erroneous signification, he will not be troubled by me on
that account : but because I think that it cannot be retained
without great danger, and that, on the contrary, its abolition
would be very beneficial to the Church, I would neither use
it myself, nor wish it to be used by others who may consult
my opinion.
IX. Perhaps I may be thought to have raised a great pre-
judice against myself, by confessing that all the ecclesiastical
writers, except Augustine, have treated this subject with such
ambiguities or variations, that nothing certain can be learned
from their writings. For some will interpret this, as though 1
intended to deprive them of the right of giving their suffrages,
because their opinions are eQI adverse to mine. But I have
had no other object in view than simply and faithfully to con-
sult the benefit of pious minds, who, if they wait to discover
the sentiments of the fathers on this subject, will fluctuate in
j»crpetual uncertainty. At one time they teach man, despoiled
(m) 2 Cor. iii. 17. (o) 2 Peter ii. 19. (^) John xv. 5.