44. Knowing that their father would condemn their design, Lot’s daughters thought it
necessary to fulfill it without his knowledge. We are told that they made him drunk, so that
he was unaware of what happened. His guilt therefore is not that of incest, but of drunken-
ness. This, too, is condemned by the eternal law, which allows meat and drink only as re-
quired by nature for the preservation of health. There is, indeed, a great difference between
a drunk man and an habitual drunkard; for the drunkard is not always drunk, and a man
may be drunk on one occasion without being a drunkard. However, in the case of a righteous
man, we require to account for even one instance of drunkenness. What can have made
Lot consent to receive from his daughters all the cups of wine which they went on mixing
for him, or perhaps giving him unmixed? Did they feign excessive grief, and did he resort
to this consolation in their loneliness, and in the loss of their mother, thinking that they
were drinking too, while they only pretended to drink? But this does not seem a proper
method for a righteous man to take in consoling his friends when in trouble. Had the
289
daughters learned in Sodom some vile art which enabled them to intoxicate their father
with a few cups, so that in his ignorance he might sin, or rather be sinned against? But it is
not likely that the Scripture would have omitted all notice of this, or that God would have
allowed His servant to be thus abused without any fault of his own.
45. But we are defending the sacred Scriptures, not man’s sins. Nor are we concerned
to justify this action, as if our God had either commanded it or approved of it; or as if, when
men are called just in Scripture, it meant that they could not sin if they chose. And as, in
the books which those critics find fault with, God nowhere expresses approval of this action,
what thoughtless folly it is to bring a charge from this narrative against these writings, when
in other places such actions are condemned by express prohibitions! In the story of Lot’s
daughters the action is related, not commended. And it is proper that the judgment of God
should be declared in some cases, and concealed in others, that by its manifestation our ig-
norance may be enlightened, and that by its concealment our minds may be improved by
the exercise of recalling what we already know, or our indolence stimulated to seek for an
explanation. Here, then, God, who can bring good out of evil, made nations arise from this
origin, as He saw good, but did not bring upon His own Scriptures the guilt of man’s sin.
It is God’s writing, but not His doing; He does not propose these things for our imitation,
but holds them up for our warning.
46. Faustus’ effrontery appears notably in his accusing Isaac also, the son of Abraham
of pretending that his wife Rebecca was his sister.855 For as regards the family of Rebecca
Scripture is not silent, and it appears that she was his sister in the well-known sense of the
word. His concealing that she was his wife is not surprising, nor is it insignificant, if he did
it in imitation of his father, so that he can be justified on the same grounds. We need only
855 Gen. xxvi. 7.
492
Faustus states his objections to the morality of the law and the prophets,…