Scotland, gave me great satisfaction, especially the last of them, for peculiar reasons. This
much I think myself bound to say. I have many a time, for some years, designed to claim
humbly the privilege of correspondence with you. What has made me defer doing it so long,
when some of my brethren and good acquaintances have been favoured with it for a consid-
erable time, it is needless now to mention. I shall only say, I have blamed myself for neglect
in that matter. I do now earnestly desire a room in your prayers and friendship, and a letter
from you sometimes, when you have occasion to write to Scotland; and I shall wish to be
lxxxiv
as regular as I can in making a return. With your permission, I propose to trouble you now
and then with the proposal of doubts and difficulties that I meet with, and am exercised by;
as for other reasons, so because some solutions in the two mentioned performances were
peculiarly agreeable to me, and I find from these discourses, that wherein I have differed in
some things from many others, my sentiments have harmonized with Mr. Edwards. This
especially was the case in some things contained in your ‘Thoughts concerning the Revival
of Religion in New England.’ All the apology I make for using such freedom, though altogether
unacquainted, is that you will find from my short attestation in Mr. Robe’s Narrative, I am
no enemy to you or to the work you have been engaged in, and which you have defended
in a way I could not but much approve of. Also my friend and countryman, the Rev. Mr.
Robert Abercrombie, will inform you about me, if you have occasion to see him or hear
from him.
I longed to see somewhat about impressions respecting facts and future events, &c.
whether by scripture texts or otherwise, made on the minds of good people, and supposed
to be from the Lord; for I have had too good occasion to know the hurtful, yea, pernicious
tendency of this principle, as commonly managed, upon many persons in manifold instances
and various respects. It has indeed surprised me much, that wise, holy, and learned divines,
as well as others, have supposed this a spiritual experience, an answer of prayers, an evidence
of being highly favoured by the Lord, &c. and I was exceeding glad, that the Lord had directed
you to give so seasonable a caveat against what I am assured you had the best reason to term,
‘A handle in the hand of the devil,’ &c. I was only sorry your then design had not permitted
you to say more on that point. It merits a volume; and the proper full discussion of it would
be one of the most seasonable and effectual services done the church of Christ, and interest
of vital religion through the world, that I know of. I rejoice to find there is a good deal more
on that subject interspersed in your ‘Treatise of Religious Affections,’ which I have got, but
could not as yet regularly peruse. I humbly think the Lord calls you, dear Sir, to consider
every part of that point in the most critical manner, and to represent fully the consequences
resulting from the several principles in that matter, which good people, as well as others,
have been so fond of. And as (if I do not mistake) Providence has already put that in your
hand as a part of your generation-work, so it will give me, as well as others, vast satisfaction
to find more said on the subject by you, if you do not find what is in the mentioned treatises
167
CHAPTER XIV. Mistakes extensively prevalent at this time, as to the nature…