Chapter XI.—The Heresiarchs of that Age.
1. “For Valentinus came to Rome under Hyginus, flourished under Pius, and remained
183
until Anicetus.1065 Cerdon1066 also, Marcion’s1067 predecessor, entered the Church in the
time of Hyginus, the ninth1068 bishop, and made confession, and continued in this way,
now teaching in secret, now making confession again, and now denounced for corrupt
doctrine and withdrawing1069 from the assembly of the brethren.”
2. These words are found in the third book of the work Against Heresies. And again in
the first book he speaks as follows concerning Cerdon:1070 “A certain Cerdon, who had
1065 Valentinus is the best known of the Gnostics. According to Epiphanius (Hær. XXXI. 2) he was born on
the coast of Egypt, and studied Greek literature and science at Alexandria. The same writer, on the authority of
the lost Syntagma of Hippolytus, informs us that he taught in Cyprus, and this must have been before he went
to Rome. The direct statement of Irenæus as to the date of his activity there is confirmed by Tertullian, and
perhaps by Clement of Alexandria, and is not to be doubted. Since Hyginus held office in all probability from
137–141, and Anicetus from 154 or 155 to 166 or 167, Valentinus must have been in Rome at least thirteen
years. His chronological position between Basilides and Marcion (as given by Clement of Alexandria, Strom.
VII. 17) makes it probable that he came to Rome early in Antoninus’ reign and remained there during all or the
most of that reign, but not longer. Valentinus’ followers divided into two schools, an Oriental and an Italian,
and constituted by far the most numerous and influential Gnostic sect. His system is the most profound and
artistic of the Gnostic systems, and reveals great depth and power of mind. For an excellent account of Valentinus
and Valentinianism, see Lipsius’ article in the Dict. of Christ. Biog. Vol. IV. Valentinus occupies a prominent
place in all works on Gnosticism.
1066 Cerdon is best known as the teacher of Marcion. Epiphanius (Hær. XLI.) and Philaster (Hær. XLIV.)
call him a native of Syria. Epiphanius speaks of a sect of Cerdonians, but there seems never to have been such
a sect, and his disciples probably early became followers of Marcion, who joined Cerdon soon after reaching
Rome. It is not possible to distinguish his teachings from those of his pupil, Marcion. Hippolytus (X. 15) treats
Cerdon and Marcion together, making no attempt to distinguish their doctrines. Irenæus, in the passage quoted,
and the lost Syntagma of Hippolytus (represented by Pseudo-Tertullian’s Adv. Hær. and by Epiphanius) distin-
guish the two, treating Cerdon separately but very briefly. The doctrines of Cerdon, however, given by them,
are identical with or at least very similar to the known views of Marcion. If they were really Cerdon’s positions
before Marcion came to him, then his influence over Marcion was most decided.
1067 On Marcion, see below, note 24.
1068 The Latin text of Irenæus here reads “eighth” instead of “ninth.” See below, note 7.
1069 ἐφιστ€μενος. This is commonly taken to mean that Cerdon was excommunicated. But as Valesius remarks,
the participle is strictly middle, not passive. The distinction, however, cannot be insisted upon in the present
case, and therefore we cannot determine decisively whether Cerdon was excluded by the congregation or excluded
himself.
1070 Irenæus, Adv. Hær. I. 27. 1–2.
The Heresiarchs of that Age.
403
The Heresiarchs of that Age.