When I had finished, the Teacher
thus replied, You have attacked the doctrines connected with the
Resurrection with some spirit, in the way of rhetoric as it is called;
you have coursed round and round the truth with plausibly subversive
arguments; so much so, that those who have not very carefully
considered this mysterious truth might possibly be affected in their
view of it by the likelihood of those arguments, and might think that
the difficulty started against what has been advanced was not
altogether beside the point. But, she proceeded, the truth does not lie
in these arguments, even though we may find it impossible to give a
rhetorical answer to them, couched in equally strong language. The true
explanation of all these questions is still stored up in the hidden
treasure-rooms of Wisdom, and will not come to the light until that
moment when we shall be taught the mystery of the Resurrection by the
reality of it; and then there will be no more need of phrases to
explain the things which we now hope for. Just as many questions might
be started for debate amongst people sitting up at night as to the kind
of thing that sunshine is, and then the simple appearing of it in all
its beauty would render any verbal description superfluous, so every
calculation that tries to arrive conjecturally at the future state will
be reduced to nothingness by the object of our hopes, when it comes
upon us. But since it is our duty not to leave the arguments brought
against us in any way unexamined, we will expound the truth as to these
points as follows. First let us get a clear notion as to the scope of
this doctrine; in other words, what is the end that Holy Scripture has
in view in promulgating it and creating the belief in it. Well, to
sketch the outline of so vast a truth and to embrace it in a
definition, we will say that the Resurrection is “the
reconstitution of our nature in its original form The
actual language of this definition is Platonic (cf. Sympos. p.
193 D), but it is Gregory’s constant formula for the Christian
Resurrection; see De Hom. Opif. c. 17; In Ecclesiast. I.
p. 385 A; Funeral Oration for Pulcheria, III. p. 523 C; Orat.
de Mortuis, III. p. 632 C; De Virginitate, c. xii. p.
358..” But in that form of life, of which
God Himself was the Creator, it is reasonable to believe that there was
neither age nor infancy nor any of the sufferings arising from our
present various infirmities, nor any kind of bodily affliction
whatever. It is reasonable, I say, to believe that God was the Creator
of none of these things, but that man was a thing divine before his
humanity got within reach of the assault of evil; that then, however,
with the inroad of evil, all these afflictions also broke in upon him.
Accordingly a life that is free from evil is under no necessity
whatever of being passed amidst the things that result from evil. It
follows that when a man travels through ice he must get his body
chilled; or when he walks in a very hot sun that he must get his skin
darkened; but if he has kept clear of the one or the other, he escapes
these results entirely, both the darkening and the chilling; no one, in
fact, when a particular cause was removed, would be justified in
looking for the effect of that particular cause. Just so our nature,
becoming passional, had to encounter all the necessary results of a
life of passion: but when it shall have started back to that state of
passionless blessedness, it will no longer encounter the inevitable
results of evil tendencies. Seeing, then, that all the infusions of the
life of the brute into our nature were not in us before our humanity
descended through the touch of evil into passions, most certainly, when
we abandon those passions, we shall abandon all their visible results.
No one, therefore, will be justified in seeking in that other life for
the consequences in us of any passion. Just as if a man, who, clad in a
ragged tunic, has divested himself of the garb, feels no more its disgrace upon
him, so we too, when we have cast off that dead unsightly tunic made
from the skins of brutes and put upon us (for I take the “coats
of skins” to mean that conformation belonging to a brute nature
with which we were clothed when we became familiar with passionate
indulgence), shall, along with the casting off of that tunic, fling
from us all the belongings that were round us of that skin of a brute;
and such accretions are sexual intercourse, conception, parturition,
impurities, suckling, feeding, evacuation, gradual growth to full size,
prime of life, old age, disease, and death. If that skin is no longer
round us, how can its resulting consequences be left behind within us?
It is folly, then, when we are to expect a different state of things in
the life to come, to object to the doctrine of the Resurrection on the
ground of something that has nothing to do with it. I mean, what has
thinness or corpulence, a state of consumption or of plethora, or any
other condition supervening in a nature that is ever in a flux, to do
with the other life, stranger as it is to any fleeting and transitory
passing such as that? One thing, and one thing only, is required for
the operation of the Resurrection; viz. that a man should have lived,
by being born; or, to use rather the Gospel words, that “a man
should be born ἐγεννηθη. S. John xvi. 21 into the
world”; the length or briefness of the life, the manner, this or
that, of the death, is an irrelevant subject of inquiry in connection
with that operation. Whatever instance we take, howsoever we suppose
this to have been, it is all the same; from these differences in life
there arises no difficulty, any more than any facility, with regard to
the Resurrection. He who has once begun to live must necessarily go on
having once lived τὸν γὰρ τοῦ
ζῆν
ἀρξάμενον,
ζῆσαι χρὴ
πάντως. The
present infinitive here expresses only a new state of existence, the
aorist a continued act. The aorist may have this force, if (as a whole)
it is viewed as a single event in past time. Cf. Appian.
Bell. Civ. ii. 91, ἦλθον,
εἶδον,
ἐνίκησα., after his
intervening dissolution in death has been repaired in the
Resurrection.