guage. “For,” says he, “to ascribe homonyms, drawn from analogy, to human thought and
conception is the work of a mind that has lost all judicial sense, and that studies the words
of the Lord with an enfeebled understanding and dishonest habit of thought.” Mercy on us!
what a logical argument! how scientifically it proceeds to its conclusion! Who after this will
dare to speak up for the cause of conception, when such a stench is poured forth from his
mouth upon those who attempt speaking? I suppose, then, that we, who do attempt speaking,
must forbear to examine his argument, for fear of his stirring up against us the cesspool of
his abuse. And verily it is weak-minded1144 to let ourselves be irritated by childish absurdities.
We will therefore allow our insolent adversary full liberty to indulge in his method as he
will. But we will return to the Master’s argument, that thence too we may muster reinforce-
ments for the truth. Eunomius has been reminded of “analogy” and has perceived “the
homonyms to be derived from it.” Now where or from whom did he learn these terms? Not
from Moses, not from the Prophets and Apostles, not from the Evangelists. It is impossible
that he should have learned them from the teaching of any Scripture. How came he, then,
to use them? The very word which describes this or that signification of a thought as analogy,
is it not the invention of the thinking faculty of him who utters it1145? How is it, then, that
he fails to perceive that he is using the views he fights against as his allies in the war? For he
makes war against our principle of words being formed by the operation of conception, and
would endeavour to establish, by the aid of words formed on that very principle, that it is
unlawful to use them. “It is not,” says he, “the teaching of any of the sacred writers.” To
whom, then, of the ancients do you yourself ascribe the term “ungenerate,” and its being
predicated of the essence of God? or is it allowable for you, when you want to establish some
of your impious conclusions, to coin and invent terms to your own liking; but if anything
is said by some one else in contravention of your impiety, to deprive your adversary of
similar licence? Great indeed would be the power you would assume if you could make good
your claim to such authority as this, that what you refuse to others should be allowable to
you alone, and that what you yourself presume to do by virtue of it, you should prevent
others from doing. You condemn, as by an edict, the doctrine that these names were applied
to Christ as a result of conception, because none of the sacred writers have declared that
they ought so to be applied. How, then, can you lay down the law that the Divine essence
282
should be denoted by the word “ungenerate”—a term which none of the sacred writers can
be shown to have handed down to us? For if this is the test of the right use of words, that
only such shall be employed as the inspired word of Scripture shall authorize, the word
“ungenerate” must be erased from your own writings, since none of the sacred writers has
1144 ῏Η μικροψύχων κ.τ.λ. Oehler’s stopping here (and accent) is better than that of the Codices. i.e.
ὑποκινήσειεν, ἢ κ.τ.λ.
1145 In other words, analogy implies thought (λόγος).
531
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.