CL. Letter of Theodoretus, Bishop of Cyrus, to Joannes, Bishop of
Antioch.
2152
I have been much distressed at
reading the anathematisms which you have sent to request me to refute
in writing, and to make plain to all their heretical sense. I have been
distressed at the thought that one appointed to the shepherd’s
office, entrusted with the charge of so great a flock and appointed to
heal the sick among his sheep, is both himself unsound, and that to a
terrible degree, and is endeavouring to infect his lambs with his
disease and treats the sheep of his folds with greater cruelty than
that of wild beasts. They, indeed, tear and rend the sheep that are
dispersed and separated from the flock; but he in its very midst, and
while thought to be its saviour and its guardian introduces secret
error among the victims of their confidence in him. Against an open
assault it is possible to take precautions, but when an attack is made
in the guise of friendship, its victim is found off his guard and hurt
is easily done him. Hence foes who make war from within are far more
dangerous than those who attack from without.
I am yet more grieved that it
should be in the name of true religion and with the dignity of a
shepherd that he should give utterance to his heretical and blasphemous
words, and renew that vain and impious teaching of Apollinarius which
was long ago stamped out. Besides all this there is the fact that he
not only supports these views but even dares to anathematize those who
decline to participate in his blasphemies;—if he is really the
author of these productions and they have not proceeded from some enemy
of the truth who has composed them in his name and, as the old story
has it, flung the apple of discord
2153
in the
midst, and so fanned the flame on high.
But whether this composition
comes from himself or from some other in his name, I, for my part, by
the aid of the light of the Holy Ghost, in the investigation of this
heretical and corrupt opinion, according to the measure of the power
given me, have refuted them as best I could. I have confronted them
with the teaching of evangelists and apostles. I have exposed the
monstrosity of the doctrine, and proved how vast is its divergence from
divine truth. This I have done by comparing it with the words of the
Holy Spirit, and pointing out what strange and jarring discord there is
between it and the divine.
Against the hardihood of this
anathema
tizing, thus much I will say, that Paul, the clear-voiced herald
of truth, anathematized those who had corrupted the evangelic and
apostolic teaching and boldly did so against the angels, not against
those who abided by the laws laid down by theologians; these he
strengthened with blessings, saying, “And as many as walk
according to this rule, peace be on them and mercy and on the Israel of
God.”
2154
Let then the author of these
writings reap from the Apostle’s curse the due rewards of his
labours and the harvest of his seeds of heresy. We will abide in the
teaching of the holy Fathers.
To this letter I have appended
my counter arguments, that on reading them you may judge whether I have
effectively destroyed the heretical propositions. Setting down each of
the anathematisms by itself, I have annexed the counter statement that
readers may easily understand, and that the refutation of the dogmas
may be clear.
2155
2152
This letter may be dated in February 431. Celestine and Cyril had
written to John of Antioch in relation to the condemnation of Nestorius
by the western bishops at Rome in August 430. Theodoret was at Antioch
on the arrival of these letters and hence additional probability is
given to the theory that he wrote the reply referred to in the
preceding note. Then came the publication of Cyril’s chapter or
anathemas which Theodoret undertook to refute. Letter CL. is prefixed
to his remarks on them.
2153
The “old story” is a comparatively late addition to
the myth of the marriage of Peleus.
2154
Gal. vi. 16
2155
The
Refutation of the anathematisms of Cyril is to be found in Migne Pat.
lxxvi.
Col. 393
. Vide also the prolegomena.