CHURCHMEN AND STATESMEN
he met disciplined troops under a good general ; but his victories
were none the less admirable, and if he is blameworthy it is not
on military counts.
Montrose was a Covenanter, and he became a Royalist after
a none too glorious affair with Huntly in the north ; his
defenders may justify him on the ground of changed conviction.
He denounced the peaceful counsels of Hamilton, and urged
King Charles to make war upon the Scots ; the Scots, it may
be pleaded, were in point to make war upon King Charles. It
is the shame of Montrose that he began a war which could
be conducted only on terms of the utmost brutality. He was
not directly responsible for the excesses which followed his
victories, and the slaughters which avenged them are a disgrace
to his opponents ; but none the less he might have foreseen
these results. He had no party in Scotland, but with the help
of wild, brave Irishmen and Highlanders he plunged the country
into a turmoil of useless bloodshed. Bloodshed there was,
because his men fought under the impulse of clan hatred or
for the lust of plunder ; and it was useless, because his host,
glutted with its spoils, melted away without accomplishing any-
thing serious. Fortunately for his fame, however, it rests even
less upon his victories than upon the glory of his tragic death .
The gallows was thirty-five feet high to show his shame abroad,
but his courage and devotion turned the halter into a victor's
wreath ; and men have remembered of " the great Montrose "
that he went without faltering to a hopeless expedition, and
sought a certain death at the bidding of an unworthy master.
With him died his cause, for it had little root in Scotland.
Loyal as the people were upon the whole to the principle of
monarchy, and even to the house of Stewart, they were yet more
devoted to the Presbyterian religion. If, as has been suggested,
they were in bondage to their ecclesiastical system, it was a
willing bondage, and much as its narrowness is to be deplored,
f 83