course with any man; those statements are not irreconcilable, so as to prove that one or both
writers must be false. It will appear on reflection that both accounts might be true; for
Joseph might be called the husband of Mary, though she was his wife only in affection, and
in the intercourse of the mind, which is more intimate than that of the body. In this way it
might be proper that the husband of the virgin-mother of Christ should have a place in the
list of Christ’s ancestors. It might also be the case that some of David’s blood flowed in
Mary herself, so that the flesh of Christ, although produced from a virgin, still owed its origin
to David’s seed. But as, in fact, both statements are made by one and the same writer, who
informs us both that Joseph was the husband of Mary and that the mother of Christ was a
virgin, and that Christ was of the seed of David, and that Joseph is in the list of Christ’s
progenitors in the line of David, those who prefer the authority of the sacred Gospel to that
of heretical fiction must conclude that Mary was not unconnected with the family of David,
and that she was properly called the wife of Joseph, because being a woman she was in
spiritual alliance with him, though there was no bodily connection. Joseph, too, it is plain,
could not be omitted in the genealogy; for, from the superiority of his sex, such an omission
would be equivalent to a denial of his relation to the woman with whom he was inwardly
united; and believers in Christ are taught not to think carnal connection the chief thing in
marriage, as if without this they could not be man and wife, but to imitate in Christian
wedlock as closely as possible the parents of Christ, that so they may have the more intimate
union with the members of Christ.
9. We believe that Mary, as well as Joseph, was of the family of David, because we believe
the Scriptures, which assert both that Christ was of the seed of David after the flesh, and
that His mother was the Virgin Mary, He having no human father. Therefore, whoever
denies the relationship of Mary to David, evidently opposes the pre-eminent authority of
these passages of Scripture; and to maintain this opposition he must bring evidence in
support of his statement from writings acknowledged by the Church as canonical and
catholic, not from any writings he pleases. In the matters of which we are now treating,
316
only the canonical writings have any weight with us; for they only are received and acknow-
ledged by the Church spread over all the world, which is itself a fulfillment of the prophecies
regarding it contained in these writings. Accordingly, I am not bound to admit the unca-
nonical account of Mary’s birth which Faustus adopts, that her father was a priest of the
tribe of Levi, of the name of Joachim. But even were I to admit this account, I should still
contend that Joachim must have in some way belonged to the family of David, and had
somehow been adopted from the tribe of Judah into that of Levi; or if not he, one of his
ancestors; or, at least, that while born in the tribe of Levi, he had still some relation to the
line of David; as Faustus himself acknowledges that Mary, though belonging to the tribe of
Levi, could be given to a husband of the tribe of Judah; and he expressly says that if Mary
were Joseph’s daughter, the name Son of David would be applicable to Christ. In this way,
537
Faustus recurs to the genealogical difficulty and insists that even according…