Section I—God's SeekingIn 1 Samuel 13:14 the prophet is represented as saying to Saul, "The Lord has sought out a man after his own heart and appointed him leader of his own people." God was seeking a true man to represent Him in the government of His people. It is peculiar to notice how this language is used by the prophet of Judah's declining kingdom, "I looked for a man among them... but I found none" (Ezekiel 22:30). God is represented as seeking for a man who can understand His thoughts and represent His will. Even David afterwards failed to meet His expectation. And it was not until the Lord Jesus at length stood on Jordan's banks, the first spotless man since Adam failed, that God at length could say, "This is my Son, whom I love; with him I am well pleased" (Matthew 3:17).
God's Man
Saul had utterly failed and God was seeking for a man to take his place. But a little later the language changes and He exclaims, "I have found David my servant; with my sacred oil I have anointed him" (Psalms 89:20). God has discovered a true man, or, as the inspired Scriptures expresses it, "a man after my own heart; he will do everything I want him to do" (Acts 13:22).
What God wanted was a man after His heart. Saul was a man after his own heart and after the world's heart. He represented man's ideals of manhood and he aimed to gratify his own ambitions and work out his own plans. God, the true theocratic King of Israel, wanted a man that would simply represent Him, that would catch His thought and reproduce it and work it out in his life. The same testimony is borne to David elsewhere, when it is said, "David had served God's purpose in his own generation" (Acts 13:36). The aim of David's life was to do the will of God.
But there is a third passage in this chain of references which completes the story of David's call. It is 1 Samuel 16:1: "Fill your horn with oil and be on your way; I am sending you to Jesse of Bethlehem. I have chosen one of his sons to be king." God had been seeking a man and He had found him at last, and here the secret is told: "I have chosen one of his sons to be king." The reason he met God's expectations was because God had provided him. The people provided Saul. He was their choice; but God provided David contrary to the expectations of man and all outward appearances or probabilities. God never will find things that will satisfy Him until He first provides them. The secret of pleasing God is to possess God, and let Him possess you; for He gives what He commands and enables for that which He requires.
The Contrast
As we look at these two men—Saul and David—it is not strange if we should sometimes be perplexed in reference to God's strong preference of the one and unqualified rejection of the other, for there was much in Saul to commend, and there was much in David to condemn. Saul was naturally noble, generous and brave. The very act of the character of Jonathan, his son, implies that there must have been something naturally good in the character of his father, so far as any fallen man can have any good in him. Then the early life of Saul has many attractive features. He seems to have been a dutiful son, seeking industriously for his father's lost asses, and when he failed to find them he quickly responds to the suggestion to go to the prophet and ask counsel of God.
There were some elements of piety apparent in his conduct; and when Samuel gave him his extraordinary commission, he behaved himself with singular propriety. He kept his secret well. He opened his heart to receive the Holy Spirit, who came upon him in a peculiar power. He joined a band of prophets and sang and ministered like them. If we except excessive humility in connection with his inauguration—in his hiding among the stuff—he seemed unobtrusive and becoming in his deportment.
His first exploits as commander and king of Israel's hosts were marked; and still later in his life attachment to David breaks out in the midst of his wild and passionate vindictiveness, and he breaks down and cries like a baby when he discovers the generosity of the man whose life he had been seeking.
Then, on the other hand, David had most glaring faults, notwithstanding all the beautiful traits of his personal character and his deep and genuine piety.
God's Word does not excuse the unbridled lust and the cool deliberate cruelty with which he could, as Nathan expresses it, snatch the one ewe lamb from the bosom of his faithful servant and soldier, Uriah, and then calmly and cunningly send that brave and loyal man, in the very ardor of his devotion to his king, right into the jaws of death, on purpose to get rid of his interference with his royal master's shameful selfishness. The worst of all is the torpor and paralysis of David's conscience, which for two whole years was utterly insensible to the double-dyed crime until God's strong reproof and chastening at length brought him to his senses, and struck a flash of light into his deadened moral sensibilities. God's faithful Word always tells the worst about the subjects of His grace. How then can we explain this strong language of preference in which God speaks of David and the unequivocal censure which condemned and rejected Saul?
Self-Will and God's Will
1. Saul represented self-will; David represents God's will. Saul's great object was to carry out his own ambition. David's chief desire was to understand and accomplish the divine purpose concerning him. When he erred he did it blindly, but the moment he recognized and realized his disobedience, he broke down like a penitent child. There was no self-will, no obstinacy, no rebellion in his spirit. There was error, terrible error. There was impulse, there was earthly passion; but his will was true to God when he really understood the will of God.
The Natural and Spiritual Man
2. Saul represented the natural man, and David the spiritual man. Saul was the embodiment of what was best in human nature. All that David had that was commendable was due to the grace of God, and speaking of his own life afterwards he could say with the deepest humility: "But who am I, and who are my people, that we should be able to give as generously as this? Everything comes from you, and we have given you only what comes from your hand" (1 Chronicles 29:14).
David was a monument of divine grace. Saul was the embodiment of human nature, self, selfishness and pride. God hates our pride and wants our weakness, self-renunciation, nothingness and dependence. David had learned the lesson of divine grace, and therefore God allowed him to be one of the princes in that kingdom of grace where our highest hope is the mercy of our God.
This is the kingdom to which we belong, and its watchword forever shall be, "Not to us, O Lord, not to us but to your name be the glory" (Psalms 115:1). It was because David had learned this watchword that God could choose him and use him notwithstanding even his gravest faults.
Sorrow Hardening or Sanctifying
3. The sorrow and sins of Saul drove him further from God, while David's brought him nearer. This is one of the most certain tests of our spiritual condition: how are we affected by our trials? Do they discourage us, or do they drive us to the bosom of our heavenly Friend? Still more searching is the question: how are we affected by our faults, our failures and our sins, when we discover them? Do we try to cover them, to excuse them, or, failing in this, do we give up in discouragement and despair, and say, "There is no use trying; everything is against me"? Poor Saul went from bad to worse, and at last turned from God and sought counsel from Satan when the heavenly Source on which he had depended failed him at last. His trust never was quite true, or he would have clung to it most closely in the hour of darkness and seeming despair. David came out of his worse faults a better man, and God could teach him, even by his temptations and sins, to die to self and rise to loftier heights of the grace of God.
The 51st Psalm
There is nothing more perfectly instructive and more supremely strong than the trial of David's heart unfolded to us in the 51st Psalm, which gives us the inner history of his soul after his greatest sin. There is no notion of trifling, there is no excuse or palliation of anything. He paints his crime in the darkest colors. He talks of blood guiltiness. No, he goes deeper than his crime, to his own personal character, and he says, "I was sinful at birth, sinful from the time my mother conceived me" (Psalms 51:5). He sees nothing good in himself. Every prop is gone, every hope is gone, as far as the human is concerned. After a life of blessed communion with God he stands self-convicted of inexcusable weakness and total depravity. Could a human soul ever be placed in a more terrible situation? But for the grace of God it would drive any man to despair and self-destruction.
But we see this man looking straight up into the dear blue sky of heaven and claiming with unshaken confidence the infinite mercy of his God, and the higher spiritual blessing that he had not before. "Wash me," he cries, "and I will be whiter than snow" (Psalms 51:7). According to the days wherein he has seen evil so he dares to claim that God will bless him with the days of heaven. His profound penitence is only surpassed by his boundless faith. He sinks to the uttermost depth, and then he rises to the very heights of heavenly grace. This was, doubtless, the crisis of David's life. Out of this he came, not only a saved, but a sanctified man, crucified to self and to sin, and knowing, even as we know, in some measure at least, the indwelling of the Holy Spirit.
David and Peter
One cannot help being reminded of the parallel between this Old Testament story and the New Testament picture of Judas and Peter. Like poor Saul, Judas was driven by his sin to desperation and suicide. Like David, Peter sinned as deeply, but he received the unspeakable grace of repentance, and there was something in his heart which led him in his darkest sorrow to the mercy of Jesus. Judas "went away and hanged himself" (Matthew 27:5). Peter "went outside and wept bitterly" (Matthew 26:75), and when Jesus was risen from the dead and stood at length upon the Galilean shore, Peter did not slink away from His presence abashed and guilty, but he leaped into the sea and was the first to swim ashore, and there he is at the blessed feet of Him whom he had once dishonored. God give us all the spirit of grace, which even in our darkest sorrows and deepest sins will turn heavenward for mercy that will pardon, and grace that waits to help in time of need (Hebrews 4:16).