A third formula was presented by Theophronius,
bishop of Tyana, as a personal statement of belief, and was widely
signed by way of approval. It insists like the Lucianic creed on the
pretemporal γέννησις, against
Marcellus, adding two other points (hypostatic pre-existence and
eternal kingdom of the Son) in the same direction, and closing with an
anathema against Marcellus, Sabellius, Paul, and all who communicate
with any of their supporters. This was of course a direct defiance of
Julius and the Westerns (Mr. Gwatkin, by a slip, assigns this anathema
to the ‘fourth’ creed).