On Moses (or Moyses, as he is called by Cyprian), see note 9,
above.
Lipsius (Chron. der
röm. Bischöfe, p. 202, note) maintains that Cornelius is
referring, at this point, not to Novatian, but to Novatus, the
Carthaginian presbyter, and that Eusebius has confounded the two men.
He bases this opinion upon the mention of the five presbyters, whom he
identifies with those who, with Novatus, separated from the
Carthaginian church in connection with the schism of Felicissimus (see
Cyprian, Ep. 39; al. 43), and also upon the fact that
Moses died before the election of Novatian as opposition bishop. In
regard to the first point, it must be noticed that, in an epistle to
Cyprian upon the schism of Novatian (Cyprian, Ep. 47; al.
50), Cornelius mentions five presbyters (including Novatus) as
connected with Novatian in his schism. Certainly it is most natural to
refer Cornelius’ words in this paragraph to the same five men.
Indeed, to speak of Novatus and the five presbyters with him would be
very peculiar, for Novatus himself was one of the five, and therefore
there were but four with him. As to the second point, it may simply be
said that Moses might well have refused to commune with Novatian,
before the election of the latter, seeing that his position would
inevitably lead to schism. There remains, therefore, no reason for
supposing Eusebius mistaken, and for referring these words to Novatus
of Carthage, instead of Novatian of Rome.