So much has been said about
Gregory’s inconsistencies, and his apparent inconsistencies are
indeed so many, that some attempt must be made to explain this feature,
to some so repulsive, in his works. One instance at all events can show
how it is possible to reconcile even the most glaring. He is not a
one-sided theologian: he is not one of those who pass always the same
judgment upon the same subject, no matter with whom he has to deal.
There could not be a harsher contradiction than that between his
statement about human generation in the Oratio Catechetica, and
that made in the treatises On Virginity and On the Making of
Man. In the O.C. everything hateful and undignified is
removed from the idea of our birth; the idea of πάθος is
not applied; “only evil brings disgrace.” But in the other
two Treatises he represents generation as a consequence of the Fall.
This contradiction arises simply from the different standpoint in each.
In the one case he is apologetic; and so he adopts a universally recognised moral
axiom. In the other he is the Christian theologian; the natural
process, therefore, takes its colouring from the Christian doctrine of
the Fall. This is the standpoint of most of his works, which are
polemical, not apologetic. But in the treatise On the Soul and the
Resurrection he introduces even a third view about generation,
which might be called that of the Christian theosophist; i.e.
generation is the means in the Divine plan for carrying Humanity to its
completion. Very similar is the view in the treatise On
Infants’ Early Deaths; “the design of all births is
that the Power which is above the universe may in all parts of the
creation be glorified by means of intellectual natures conspiring to
the same end, by virtue of the same faculty operating in all; I mean,
that of looking upon God.” Here he is speaking to the purely
philosophic instinct. It may be remarked that on this and all the
operations of Divine foreknowledge in vast world-wide relations he has
constantly striking passages, and deserves for this especially to be
studied.