As
shown in the next note, a comparison of our best sources leads us to
the year 222 as the date of the accession of Urban, and consequently of
the death of Callistus. A careful comparison of the various sources,
which differ in regard to the years of the several episcopates of
Victor, Zephyrinus, and Callistus, but agree as to the sum of the
three, leads to the result that Callistus was bishop for five years,
and therefore his accession is to be put into the year 217, and the
reign of Macrinus (see Lipsius, Chron. d. röm.
Bischöfe, p. 171 sq.). This agrees, so far as the years of our
era are concerned, with the statement of Eusebius in this chapter; but
he wrongly puts Callistus’ accession into the first year of
Alexander, which is a result of an error of a year in his reckoning of
the dates of the emperors, which runs back to Pertinax (see Lipsius, p.
7 sq.). He does not assign Callistus’ accession to the first year
of Heliogabalus because of a tradition connecting the two, but simply
because his reckoning of the lengths of the various episcopates, which
were given in the source used by him, led him to the year 217 for
Callistus’ accession, and this, according to his erroneous table
of the reigns of the emperors, was the first year of Heliogabalus. We
thus see that Eusebius is in real, though not in apparent, agreement
with the Liberian catalogue in regard to the date of Callistus’
accession, which may, therefore, be accepted as certain.
Nothing was known about
the character and life of Callistus until the discovery of
Hippolytus’ Philosophumena, or Refutation of All
Heresies (see the next chapter, note 1). In Bk. IX. of that work is
given a detailed description of him, from the pen of a very bitter
opponent. At the same time, it can hardly be doubted that at least the
groundwork of the account is true. According to Hippolytus, he was a
slave; a dishonest banker, who was punished for his dishonesty; the
author of a riot in a Jewish synagogue, who was sent as a criminal to
the mines; finally, after various other adventures, the right-hand man
of the bishop Zephyrinus, and after his death, his successor. According
to Hippolytus, he was a Patripassian, and he introduced much laxer
methods of church discipline than had hitherto been in vogue; so lax as
greatly to scandalize Hippolytus, who was a very rigid disciplinarian.
Whatever truth there may be in this highly sensational account (and we
cannot doubt that it is greatly overdrawn), it is at least certain that
Callistus took the liberal view of Christian morals and church
discipline, over against the stricter view represented by Hippolytus
and his party. It was, perhaps, owing to his popularity on this account
that, after the death of Zephyrinus, he secured the episcopacy of Rome,
for which Hippolytus was also a candidate. The latter tells us also
that Zephyrinus “set him over the cemetery,”—a most
interesting notice, as the largest catacomb in Rome bears the name of
St. Callistus, and may be the very one of which Zephyrinus made him the
superintendent.