Chapter XIX.—None of These Allegories are
Consistent.
“Nor do we find the poetical allegory about any of
the gods consistent with itself. To go no further than the
fashioning of the universe, the poets now say that nature was the first
cause of the whole creation, now that it was mind. For, say they,
the first moving and mixture of the elements came from nature, but it
was the foresight of mind which arranged them in order. Even when
they assert that it was nature which fashioned the universe, being
unable absolutely to demonstrate this on account of the traces of
design in the work, they in weave the foresight of mind in such a way
that they are able to entrap even the wisest. But we say to
them: If the world arose from self-moved nature, how did it ever
take proportion and shape, which cannot come but from a superintending
wisdom, and can be comprehended only by knowledge, which alone can
trace such things? If, on the other hand, it is by wisdom that
all things subsist and maintain order, how can it be that those things
arose from self-moved chance?