What, moreover, is the high
estate of the Almighty in which Eunomius affirms that the Son has no
share? Let those, then, who are wise in their own eyes, and prudent in
their own sight Is. v. 21., utter their
groundling opinions—they who, as the prophet says, “speak
out of the ground Is. xxix. 4..” But let us
who reverence the Word and are disciples of the Truth, or rather who
profess to be so, not leave even this assertion unsifted. We know that
of all the names by which Deity is indicated some are expressive of the
Divine majesty, employed and understood absolutely, and some are
assigned with reference to the operations over us and all creation. For
when the Apostle says “Now to the immortal, invisible, only wise
God Cf. 1 Tim. i. 17,” and the like, by these titles he
suggests conceptions which represent to us the transcendent power, but
when God is spoken of in the Scriptures as gracious, merciful, full of
pity, true, good, Lord, Physician, Shepherd, Way, Bread, Fountain,
King, Creator, Artificer, Protector, Who is over all and through all,
Who is all in all, these and similar titles contain the declaration of
the operations of the Divine loving-kindness in the creation. Those
then who enquire precisely into the meaning of the term
“Almighty” will find that it declares nothing else concerning the
Divine power than that operation which controls created things and is
indicated by the word “Almighty,” stands in a certain
relation to something. For as He would not be called a Physician, save
on account of the sick, nor merciful and gracious, and the like, save
by reason of one who stood in need of grace and mercy, so neither would
He be styled Almighty, did not all creation stand in need of one to
regulate it and keep it in being. As, then, He presents Himself as a
Physician to those who are in need of healing, so He is Almighty over
one who has need of being ruled: and just as “they that are whole
have no need of a physician Cf.
S. Matt. ix. 12, and parallel passages.,” so it follows
that we may well say that He Whose nature contains in it the principle
of unerring and unwavering rectitude does not, like others, need a
ruler over Him. Accordingly, when we hear the name
“Almighty,” our conception is this, that God sustains in
being all intelligible things as well as all things of a material
nature. For this cause He sitteth upon the circle of the earth, for
this cause He holdeth the ends of the earth in His hand, for this cause
He “meteth out leaven with the span, and measureth the waters in
the hollow of His hand Cf. Is. xl. 12 and
24.
The quotation is not verbally from the LXX.”; for this
cause He comprehendeth in Himself all the intelligible creation, that
all things may remain in existence controlled by His encompassing
power. Let us enquire, then, Who it is that “worketh all in
all.” Who is He Who made all things, and without Whom no existing
thing does exist? Who is He in Whom all things were created, and in
Whom all things that are have their continuance? In Whom do we live and
move and have our being? Who is He Who hath in Himself all that the
Father hath? Does what has been said leave us any longer in ignorance
of Him Who is “God over all Rom. ix. 5.,” Who is
so entitled by S. Paul,—our Lord Jesus Christ, Who, as He Himself
says, holding in His hand “all things that the Father hath S. John xvi. 15,” assuredly grasps all things in the
all-containing hollow of His hand and is sovereign over what He has
grasped, and no man taketh from the hand of Him Who in His hand holdeth
all things? If, then, He hath all things, and is sovereign over that
which He hath, why is He Who is thus sovereign over all things
something else and not Almighty? If heresy replies that the Father is
sovereign over both the Son and the Holy Spirit, let them first show
that the Son and the Holy Spirit are of mutable nature, and then over
this mutability let them set its ruler, that by the help implanted from
above, that which is so overruled may continue incapable of turning to
evil. If, on the other hand, the Divine nature is incapable of evil,
unchangeable, unalterable, eternally permanent, to what end does it
stand in need of a ruler, controlling as it does all creation, and
itself by reason of its immutability needing no ruler to control it?
For this cause it is that at the name of Christ “every knee
boweth, of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things under the
earth Cf. Phil. ii. 10.” For assuredly every knee would not
thus bow, did it not recognize in Christ Him Who rules it for its own
salvation. But to say that the Son came into being by the goodness of
the Father is nothing else than to put Him on a level with the meanest
objects of creation. For what is there that did not arrive at its birth
by the goodness of Him Who made it? To what is the formation of mankind
ascribed? to the badness of its Maker, or to His goodness? To what do
we ascribe the generation of animals, the production of plants and
herbs? There is nothing that did not take its rise from the goodness of
Him Who made it. A property, then, which reason discerns to be common
to all things, Eunomius is so kind as to allow to the Eternal Son! But
that He did not share His essence or His estate with the
Father—these assertions and the rest of his verbiage I have
refuted in anticipation, when dealing with his statements concerning
the Father, and shown that he has hazarded them at random and without
any intelligible meaning. For not even in the case of us who are born
one of another is there any division of essence. The definition
expressive of essence remains in its entirety in each, in him that
begets and in him who is begotten, without admitting diminution in him
who begets, or augmentation in him who is begotten. But to speak of
division of estate or sovereignty in the case of Him Who hath all
things whatsoever that the Father hath, carries with it no meaning,
unless it be a demonstration of the propounder’s impiety. It
would therefore be superfluous to entangle oneself in such discussions,
and so to prolong our treatise to an unreasonable length. Let us pass
on to what follows.