2. But to put a more searching question still: let
Novatian tell us how he distinguishes speaking against the Son of Man
from blasphemy against the Holy Ghost. For I maintain that on his
principles men who have denied Christ under persecution have only
spoken against the Son of Man, and have not blasphemed the Holy Ghost.
For when a man is asked if he is a Christian, and declares that he is
not; obviously in denying Christ, that is the Son of Man, he does no
despite to the Holy Ghost. But if his denial of Christ involves a
denial of the Holy Ghost, this heretic can perhaps tell us how the Son
of Man can be denied without sinning against the Holy Ghost. If he
thinks that we are here intended by the term Holy Ghost to understand
the Father, no mention at all of the Father is made by the denier in
his denial. When the apostle Peter, taken aback by a maid’s
question, denied the Lord, did he sin against the Son of Man or against
the Holy Ghost? If Novatian absurdly twists Peter’s words,
“I know not the man,” Matt. xxvi. 74. to mean a
denial not of Christ’s Messiahship but of His humanity, he will
make the Saviour a liar, for He foretold Matt. xxvi. 33–35; Joh. xiii.
38. that
He Himself, that is His divine Sonship, must be denied. Now, when Peter
denied the Son of God, he wept bitterly and effaced his threefold
denial by a threefold confession. Joh. xxi. 15–17. His sin,
therefore, was not the sin against the Holy Ghost which can never be
forgiven. It is obvious, then, that this sin involves blasphemy,
calling one Beelzebub for his actions, whose virtues prove him to be
God. If Novatian can bring an instance of a renegade who has called
Christ Beelzebub, I will at once give up my position and admit that
after such a fall the denier can win no forgiveness. To give way under
torture and to deny oneself to be a Christian is one thing, to say that
Christ is the devil is another. And this you will yourself see if you
read the passage Viz. Matt. xii. 32, quoted above. attentively.