ST. ANDREWS UNIVERSITY
are among the commonplaces of history. Recent research,
however, has brought to light one fresh fact regarding his
disastrous visit to Coimbra : his accusation before the Inquisi-
tion was not due to the undying hate of either the Franciscans
or the Cardinal, as has sometimes been supposed, but simply
to the imprudence with which he expressed his liberal opinions
in Portugal itself. After many vicissitudes he returned home,
became the friend and preceptor of Queen Mary until the tragic
year 1566, rose to be Principal of St. Leonard's College, and
finally acted as tutor to the young King James VI.
In such a life-history it is possible to see a broad-minded
scholar, little touched by religious ideals, whose political views
were warped by mere clan prejudice (he was a Lennox man
and loved Darnley), and whose services to education, save by
the way of a high example, were hardly practical enough to be
very beneficial to his country. Why, then, does Scotland place
him in the same category as John Knox and Andrew Melville ?
The one great point of contact lies in their common
independence and love of truth. Buchanan detested the false
and inefficient no matter how old and how venerable it might
be. The grammar of Alexander, the scholastic philosophy, the
Order of St. Francis, the absolute power of the King, all
fell beneath his displeasure, and he lashed them with the whip
of his scorn—a scorn not altogether justified. If scholastic
philosophy is not the chief end of life, neither is Latin ; and
though absolute monarchy is certainly a bad thing, tyrannicide
is scarcely a better. Buchanan seems to have been a man of
few original ideas who drew his inspiration rather from antiquity
than from the world around him. He was beyond all doubt
a great Latinist, but the astronomical poem upon which he
hoped to base a lasting reputation is absurd, while the much
belauded treatise on monarchical power is little more than
a livre de cirConstance. But he wrote with the finest pen in
78