For instance, his progressive stress on the Unity
of the Godhead in Father, Son, and Spirit is but the following up of
the thought expressed de Incarn. 17. 1 ἐν μόνῳ
τῷ ἑαυτοῦ
Πατρὶ ὅλος ὢν
κατὰ πάντα. It
may be noted that he argues also from the idea of the Trinity to the
coessential Godhead of the Spirit, ad Serap. i. 28, sq.,
Τριὰς δέ
ἐστιν οὐχ ἕως
ὀνομάτος
μόνον…ἀλλὰ ἀληθεί&
139· καὶ
ὑπάρξει
τριάς…εἰπάτωσαν
πάλιν…τριάς
ἐστιν ἢ
δυάς; and that he meets the difficulty (see
infra, p. 438, ten lines from end, also Petav. Trin. VII.
xiv.) of differentiating the relation of the Spirit to the Father from
the γέννησις of the
Son by a confession of ignorance and a censure upon those who assume
that they can search out the deep things of God (ib.
17–19). The principle might be applied to this point which is
laid down de Decr. 11, that ‘an act’ belonging to
the essence of God, cannot, by virtue of the simplicity of the Divine
Nature, be more than one: the ‘act’ therefore of divine
γέννησις (the
nature of which we do not know) cannot apply to the Spirit but only to
the Son. But I do not recollect any passage in which Athanasius draws
this conclusion from his own premises. The language of Athanasius on
the procession of the Spirit is unstudied. In Exp. Fid. 4, he
appears to adopt the ‘procession’ of the Spirit from the
Father through the Son (after Dionysius, see Sent. Dion.
17). In Serap. i. 2, 20, 32, iii. 1, he speaks of the Spirit as
ἴδιον
τοῦ Λόγου, just as the
Word is ἴδιος τοῦ
Πατρός. His language on the
subject, expressing the idea common to East and West (under the
cloud of logomachies which envelop the subject) might possibly furnish
the basis of an ‘eirenicon’ between the two separated
portions of Christendom. In explaining the ‘theophanies’ of
the Old Testament, Athanasius takes a position intermediate between
that of the Apologists, &c. (supr., p. xxiii.) who referred
them to the Word, and that of Augustine who referred them to Angels
only. According to Athanasius the ‘Angel’ was and was not
the Word: regarded as visible he was an Angel simply, but the Voice was
the Divine utterance through the Word (see Orat. iii. 12, 14;
de Syn. 27, Anath 15, note; also Serap. i. 14).