as they come to the ordinance without professing godliness, they cannot properly be called
professing saints.
Here it may be said, that although no explicit and formal profession of those things
which belong to true piety, be required of them; yet there are many things they do, that are
a virtual and implicit profession of these things: such as their owning the christian covenant,
their owning God the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost to be their God; and by their visibly
joining in the public prayers and singing God’s praises, there is a show and implicit profession
of supreme respect to God and love to him; by joining in the public confessions, they make
a show of repentance; by keeping Sabbaths and hearing the word, they make a show of a
spirit of obedience; by offering to come to sacraments, they make a show of love to Christ
and a dependence on his sacrifice.
To this I answer; It is a great mistake, if any one imagines, that all these external per-
formances are of the nature of a profession, of any thing that belongs to saving grace, as they
are commonly used and understood. None of them are so, according to the doctrines that
are taught and embraced, and the customs that are established, in such churches as proceed
on the footing of the principles forementioned. For what is professing, but exhibiting, uttering,
or declaring, either by intelligible words, or by other established signs that are equivalent?
439
But in such churches, neither their publicly saying, that they avouch God the Father, Son,
and Holy Ghost, to be their God, and that they give themselves up to him, and promise to obey
all his commands, nor their coming to the Lord’s supper, or to any other ordinances, are
taken for expressions or signs, of any thing belonging to the essence of christian piety. But
on the contrary, the public doctrine, principle, and custom in such churches, establishes a
diverse use of these words and signs. People are taught, that they may use them all, and not
so much as make any pretence to the least degree of sanctifying grace; and this is the estab-
lished custom. So they are used, and so they are understood. And therefore whatever some
of these words and signs may in themselves most properly and naturally import, they entirely
cease to be significations of any such thing among people accustomed to understand and
use them otherwise; and so cease to be of the nature of a profession of christian piety. There
can be no such thing among such a people, as either an explicit or implicit profession of
godliness, by any thing which (by their established doctrine and custom) an unregenerate
man may and ought to say and perform, knowing himself to be so. For let the words and
actions otherwise signify what they will, yet people have in effect agreed among themselves,
that persons who use them need not intend them so, and that others need not understand
them so. And hence they cease to be of the nature of any pretension to grace. And surely it
is an absurdity to say, that men openly and solemnly profess grace, and yet do not so much
as pretend to it. If a certain people should agree, and it should be an established principle
among them, that men might and ought to use such and such words to their neighbours,
which according to their proper signification were a profession of entire love and devoted
1760
SECTION I. Church members should be visible saints.