We must now glance at the important period of
developed Catholicism marked especially by the names of Irenæus, Tertullian, and
Clement, the period of a consolidated
organisation, a (relatively) fixed Canon of the New Testament, and a
catholic rule of faith (see above, and Lumby, Creeds, ch. i.;
Heurtley, Harmonia Symbolica, i.–viii.). The problem of
the period which now begins (180–250) was that of Monarchianism; the Divinity of Christ must be reconciled
with the Unity of God. Monarchianism is in itself the expression of the
truth common to all monotheism, that the ἄρχη or
Originative Principle is strictly and Personally One and one only (in
contrast to the plurality of ἀρχικαὶ
ὑποστάσεις,
see Newman, Arians4, p. 112 note). No Christian
deliberately maintains the contrary. The Apologists, as we have seen,
tended to emphasise the distinction of Father and Son; but this
tendency makes of necessity in the direction of
‘subordination;’ and any distinction of
‘Persons’ or Hypostases in the Godhead involves to a
Monotheist some subordination, in order to save the principle
of the Divine Monarchia.’ The
Monarchian denied any subordination or distinction of hypostases
within the Godhead. This tendency we have now to follow up. We do not
meet with it as a problem in Irenæus. (He
‘is said to have written against it,’ Newman,
Ar.4, p. 117, citing Dodw. in Iren.) This
scholar of pupils of Apostles stands in the lines of the Asiatic
theology. He is the successor of Ignatius and Polycarp. We find him, in
sharp contrast to the Apologists, giving full expression to the
revelation of God in Jesus (the ‘Son is the Measure of the
Father, for He contains Him’), and the union of man with God in
the Saviour, as the carrying out of the original destiny of man, by the
destruction of sin, which had for the time frustrated it (III. xviii.
p. 211, Deus antiquam hominis plasmationem in se recapitulans). Hence
the ‘deification’ of man’s nature by union with
Christ (a remarkable point of contact with Athanasius, see note on
de Incar. 54. 3); incorruption is attained to by the knowledge
of God (cf. John xvii. 3) through faith (IV.
xx.); we cannot comprehend
God, but we learn to know Him by His Love (ib.). At the same time we trace the
influence of the Apologists here and there in his Christology (III. 6,
19, and the explanation of the ‘Theophanies,’ iv. 20). But
in his younger contemporary Tertullian, the
reaction of Monarchianism makes itself felt. He is himself one of the
Apologists, and at the same time under Asiatic influences. The
two trains of influence converge in the name Trinitas, which he
is the first to use (τρίας first in the Asiatic
Apologist Theophilus). In combating the Monarchian Praxeas (see below)
he carries subordinationism very far (cf. Hermog. 3. ‘fuit
tempus cum Ei filius non fuit’), he distinguishes the Word as
‘rationalis deus’ from eternity, and
‘sermonalis’ not from eternity (cf. again, Theophilus,
supra). The Generation of the Son is a προβολή (also
‘eructare’ from Ps. xlv. 1), but the divine ‘Substance’
remains the same (river and fountain, sun and ray, Prax. 8, 9).
He aims at reconciling ‘subordination’ with the
‘Monarchia,’ (ib. 4). In the Incarnate Christ he
distinguishes the divine and human as accurately as Leo the Great (ib.
27, 29). In spite of inconsistencies such as were inevitable in his
strange individuality (Stoic, philosopher, lawyer, Apologist,
‘Asiatic’ theologian, Catholic, Montanist) we see in
Tertullian the starting-point of Latin Theology (but see also Harnack
ii. 287 note).