Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(On the unity of the Church, p. 421.)
The epistles have already been elucidated as the best exposition of this treatise. Little
need be added. But, to illustrate the bearings of this treatise upon the history of Christian
unity, we need only refer to the manner in which the subject was treated as soon as the
papacy was created by Nicholas I. Thus, he astounded the Greeks by his consummate audacity
(a.d. 860) in the matter of the disputed succession in Constantinople.4637 “It is our will,” he
says, “that Ignatius should appear before our envoys,” etc. He declares it the rule of the
Fathers, that, “without the consent of the Roman See and the Roman pontiff, nothing should
be decided.” Also, he affirms, “The Creator of all things has established the Princedom of
the Divine Power, which He granted to His chosen apostles. He has firmly established it on
the firm faith of the Prince of the Apostles,—that is to say, Peter,—to whom he pre-eminently
granted the first See,” etc. He was now speaking on the strength of the forged Decretals, to
which he appeals, and which he succeeded in making law for the West. He thus created the
lasting schism with the Easterns, who had never heard the like before his time.
Obviously, therefore, had Cyprian entertained such ideas, his treatise could never have
been written; for it is a masterly exposition of a curious point, viz., the fact that (1) the
Apostle Peter received the first grant alone, and yet (2) all the apostles received precisely
the same; while (1) Peter had thus a primacy of honour, but (2) in no respect any power or
authority over his brethren. On these admitted facts he constructs his theory of unity, ex-
pounding by it the actual state of the Church’s constitution. Peter’s memory he honours,
but without any less reverence for all the apostolic Sees, which over and over again he
maintains to be of equal authority and sanctity. That the Church was founded on Stephen
any more than on the Bishop of Carthage, he never imagines; for it is one thing to allow
that a bishop has succeeded an apostle at the place of his last labours, and quite another to
assume that therefore such a bishop is virtually the apostle himself. Yet this assumption is
the ground of all Roman doctrine on this point.4638
Had such been Cyprian’s idea, his Treatise on Unity must have proceeded thus: (1) “Our
Lord said to Peter only, I will give unto thee the keys; (2) to the rest of the apostles He gave
only an inferior and subject authority; (3) to the successor of Peter, therefore, at Rome, all
4637 For the Ultramontane side, consult the Histoire de Photius, etc., par M. l’Abbé Jager, p. 41, ed. Paris,
1854. For the Greeks, La Papauté Schismatique, etc., par M. l’Abbé Guettée (pp. 286, 288, etc.), Paris, 1863.
4638 “Whatever is said in commendation of St. Peter is at once transferred to the occupant of the papacy, as
if pasce oves meas had been said to Pius IX.” Burgon, Letters from Rome, p. 411, ed. 1862.
Elucidations.
1360
Elucidations.