Chapter XXX.—This
Vision Interpreted by Tertullian of the Resurrection of the Bodies of
the Dead. A Chronological Error of Our Author, Who Supposes that
Ezekiel in His
Ch. XXXI
. Prophesied Before the
Captivity.
I am well aware how they torture even this
prophecy into a proof of the allegorical sense, on the ground that by
saying, “These bones are the whole house of Israel,” He
made them a figure of Israel, and removed them from their proper
literal condition; and therefore (they contend) that there is here a
figurative, not a true prediction of the resurrection, for (they say)
the state of the Jews is one of humiliation, in a certain sense dead,
and very dry, and dispersed over the plain of the world. Therefore the
image of a resurrection is allegorically applied to their state, since
it has to be gathered together, and recompacted bone to bone (in other
words, tribe to tribe, and people to people), and to be reincorporated
by the sinews of power and the nerves of royalty, and to be brought out
as it were from sepulchres, that is to say, from the most miserable and
degraded abodes of captivity, and to breathe afresh in the way of a
restoration, and to live thenceforward in their own land of Judæa.
And what is to happen after all this? They will die, no doubt. And what
will there be after death? No resurrection from the dead, of course,
since there is nothing of the sort here revealed to Ezekiel. Well, but
the resurrection is elsewhere foretold: so that there will be one even
in this case, and they are rash in applying this
passage
to the
state of Jewish affairs; or even if it do indicate a different recovery
from the resurrection which we are maintaining, what matters it to me,
provided there be also a resurrection of the body, just as there is a
restoration of the Jewish state? In fact, by the very circumstance that
the recovery of the Jewish state is prefigured by the reincorporation
and reunion of bones, proof is offered that this event will also happen
to the bones
themselves
; for the metaphor could not have been
formed from bones, if the same thing exactly were not to be realized in
them also. Now, although there is a sketch of the true thing in
its image, the image itself still possesses a truth of its own: it must
needs be, therefore, that must have a prior existence for itself, which
is used figuratively to express some other thing. Vacuity is not a
consistent basis for a similitude, nor does nonentity form a suitable
foundation for a parable. It will therefore be right to believe that
the bones are destined to have a rehabiliment of flesh and breath, such
as it is
here
said they will have, by reason indeed of which
their renewed state could alone express the reformed condition of
Jewish affairs, which is pretended to be the meaning of this passage.
It is, however, more characteristic of a religious spirit to maintain
the truth on the authority of a literal interpretation, such as is
required
by the sense
of the inspired passage. Now, if this vision had reference to the
condition of the Jews, as soon as He had revealed to him the position
of the bones, He would at once have added, “These bones are the
whole house of Israel,” and so forth. But immediately on showing
the bones, He interrupts the scene by saying somewhat of the prospect
which is most suited to bones; without yet naming Israel, He tries the
prophet’s own faith: “Son of man, can these bones ever
live?” so that he makes answer: “O Lord, Thou
knowest.” Now God would not, you may be sure, have tried the
prophet’s faith on a point which was never to be a real one, of
which Israel should never hear,
and
in which it was not proper
to repose belief. Since, however, the resurrection of the dead
was indeed foretold, but Israel, in the distrust of his great unbelief,
was offended at it; and, whilst gazing on the condition of the
crumbling grave, despaired of a resurrection; or rather, did not direct
his mind mainly to it, but to his own harassing
circumstances,—therefore God first instructed the prophet (since
he, too, was not free from doubt), by revealing to him the process of
the resurrection, with a view to his earnest setting forth of the same.
He then charged the people to believe what He had revealed to the
prophet, telling them that they were themselves, though refusing to
believe their resurrection, the very bones which were destined to rise
again. Then in the concluding sentence He says, “And ye shall
know how that I the Lord have spoken and done these things,”
intending of course to do that of which He had spoken; but certainly
not meaning to do that which He had spoken of, if His design had been
to do something different from what He had said.