17. This parable is not a repetition of the previous one, but a stronger and more exact setting forth of the truth in hand. As is frequently our Lord’s practice in His parables, He advances from the immediate subject to something more spiritual and higher, and takes occasion from answering a cavil, to preach the sublimest truths. The garment was something outward; this wine is poured in, is something inward, the spirit of the system. The former parable respected the outward freedom and simple truthfulness of the New Covenant; this regards its inner spirit, its pervading principle. And admirably does the parable describe the vanity of the attempt to keep the new wine in the ἀσκὸςπαλαιός, the old ceremonial man, unrenewed in the spirit of his mind: ῥήγνυνταιοἱἀσκοί: the new wine is something too living and strong for so weak a moral frame; it shatters the fair outside of ceremonial seeming; and ὁοἶνοςἐκχεῖται, the spirit is lost, the man is neither a blameless Jew nor a faithful Christian; both are spoiled. And then the result: not merely the damaging, but the utter destruction of the vessel,— οἱἀσκοὶἀπολοῦνται.
According to some expositors, the new patch and new wine denote the fasting; the old garment and old bottles, the disciples. ὃδὲλέγει, τοιοῦτόνἐστινοὔπωγεγόνασινἰσχυροὶοἱμαθηταί, ἀλλ ʼ ἔτιπολλῆςδἐονταισυγκαταβάσεωςοὔπωδιὰτοῦπνεύμτοςἀνεκαινίσθησαν. οὕτωδὲδιακειμένοιςοὐχρὴβάροςἐπιτιθέναιἐπιταγμάτων. Chrysostom, Hom. in Matt. xxx. 4, p. 353. This view is stated and defended at some length by Neander, Leben Jesu, p. 346, note; but I own seems to me, as to De Wette, far-fetched. For how can fasting be called ἐπίβλημαῥάκουςἀγνάφσυ, or how compared to new wine? And Neander himself, when he comes to explain the important addition in Luke (on which see Luke 5:39, and note), is obliged to change the meaning, and understand the new wine of the spirit of the Gospel. It was and is the custom in the East to carry their wine on a journey in leather bottles, generally of goats’skin, sometimes of asses’or camels’skin. (Winer, Realwörterbuch, ‘Schlauch.’)