He goes on to add,
“Neither on the same level with the Father, nor connumerated with
the Father (for God over all is one and only Father), nor on an
equality with the Son, for the Son is only-begotten, having none
begotten with Him.” Well, for my own part, if he had only added
to his previous statement the remark that the Holy Ghost is not the
Father of the Son, I should even then have thought it idle for him to
linger over what no one ever doubted, and forbid people to form notions
of Him which not even the most witless would entertain. But since he
endeavours to establish his impiety by irrelevant and unconnected
statements, imagining that by denying the Holy Spirit to be the Father
of the Only-begotten he makes out that He is subject and subordinate, I
therefore made mention of these words, as a proof of the folly of the
man who imagines that he is demonstrating the Spirit to be subject to
the Father on the ground that the Spirit is not Father of the
Only-begotten. For what compels the conclusion, that if He be not
Father, He must be subject? If it had been demonstrated that
“Father” and “despot” were terms identical in
meaning, it would no doubt have followed that, as absolute sovereignty
was part of the conception of the Father, we should affirm that the
Spirit is subject to Him Who surpassed Him in respect of authority. But
if by “Father” is implied merely His relation to the Son,
and no conception of absolute sovereignty or authority is involved by
the use of the word, how does it follow, from the fact that the Spirit
is not the Father of the Son, that the Spirit is subject to the Father?
“Nor on an equality with the Son,” he says. How comes he to
say this? for to be, and to be unchangeable, and to admit no evil
whatsoever, and to remain unalterably in that which is good, all this
shows no variation in the case of the Son and of the Spirit. For the
incorruptible nature of the Spirit is remote from corruption equally
with that of the Son, and in the Spirit, just as in the Son, His
essential goodness is absolutely apart from its contrary, and in both
alike their perfection in every good stands in need of no
addition.