The revelation of Christ is addressed primarily
to the will not to the intellect, its appeal is to Faith not to
Theology. Theology is the endeavour of the Christian intellect to frame
for itself conceptions of matters belonging to the immediate
consequences of our faith, matters about which we must believe
something, but as to which the Lord and His Apostles have delivered
nothing formally explicit. Theology has no doubt its certainties beyond
the express teaching of our Lord and the New Testament writers; but its
work is subject to more than the usual limitations of human thought: we
deal with things outside the range of experience, with celestial
things; but ‘we have no celestial language.’ To abandon all
theology would be to acquiesce in a dumb faith: we are to teach, to
explain, to defend; the λόγος
σοφίας and λόγος
γνώσεως have from the first
been gifts of the Spirit for the building up of the Body. But we know
in part and prophesy in part, and our terms begin to fail us just in
the region where the problem of guarding the faith of the simple ends
and the inevitable metaphysic, into which all pure reflexion merges,
begins. Εἴτε οὖν
φιλοσοφητέον
εἴτε μὴ
φιλοσοφητέον,
φιλοσοφητέον,
‘man is metaphysical nolens volens:’ only let us
recollect that when we find ourselves in the region of antinomies we
are crossing the frontier line between revelation and speculation,
between the domain of theology and that of ontology. That this line is
approached in the definition of the great council no one will deny. But
it was reached by the council and by the subsequent consent of the
Church reluctantly and under compulsion. The bold assumption that we
can argue from the revelation of God in Christ to mysteries beyond our
experience was made by the Gnostics, by Arius: the Church met them by a
denial of what struck at the root of her belief, not by the claim to
erect formulæ applied merely for the lack of better into a
revealed ontology. In the terms Person, Hypostasis, Will, Essence,
Nature, Generation, Procession, we have the embodiment of ideas
extracted from experience, and, as applied to God, representing merely
the best attempt we can make to explain what we mean when we speak of
God as Father and of Christ as His Son. Even these last sacred names
convey their full meaning to us only in view of the historical person
of Christ and of our relation to God through Him. That this meaning is
based upon an absolute relation of Christ to the Father is the rock of
our faith. That relation is mirrored in the name Son of God: but what
it is in itself, when the empirical connotations of Sonship are
stripped away, we cannot possibly know. ‘Ομοούσιος
τῷ Πατρί, ἐκ
τῆς οὐσίας
τοῦ Πατρός’
these words assert at once our faith that such relation exists and our
ignorance of its nature. To the simplicity of faith it is enough to
know (and this knowledge is what our formula secures) that in Christ we
have not only the perfect Example of Human Love to God, but the direct
expression and assurance of the Father’s Love to us.