162
Historical Introduction.
In the whole history of the Church there is no council which bristles with such astonish-
ing facts as the First Council of Constantinople. It is one of the “undisputed General
Councils,” one of the four which St. Gregory said he revered as he did the four holy Gospels,
and he would be rash indeed who denied its right to the position it has so long occupied;
and yet
1. It was not intended to be an Ecumenical Synod at all.
2. It was a local gathering of only one hundred and fifty bishops.
3. It was not summoned by the Pope, nor was he invited to it.
4. No diocese of the West was present either by representation or in the person of its
bishop; neither the see of Rome, nor any other see.
5. It was a council of Saints, Cardinal Orsi, the Roman Historian, says: “Besides St.
Gregory of Nyssa, and St. Peter of Sebaste, there were also at Constantinople on account of
the Synod many other Bishops, remarkable either for the holiness of their life, or for their
zeal for the faith, or for their learning, or for the eminence of their Sees, as St. Amphilochius
of Iconium, Helladius of Cesarea in Cappadocia, Optimus of Antioch in Pisidia, Diodorus
of Tarsus, St. Pelagius of Laodicea, St. Eulogius of Edessa, Acacius of Berea, Isidorus of
Cyrus, St. Cyril of Jerusalem, Gelasius of Cesarea in Palestine, Vitus of Carres, Dionysius
of Diospolis, Abram of Batnes, and Antiochus of Samosata, all three Confessors, Bosphorus
of Colonia, and Otreius of Melitina, and various others whose names appear with honour
in history. So that perhaps there has not been a council, in which has been found a greater
number of Confessors and of Saints.”203
6. It was presided over at first by St. Meletius, the bishop of Antioch who was bishop
not in communion with Rome,204 who died during its session and was styled a Saint in the
panegyric delivered over him and who has since been canonized as a Saint of the Roman
Church by the Pope.
7. Its second president was St. Gregory Nazianzen, who was at that time liable to censure
for a breach of the canons which forbade his translation to Constantinople.
203 Orsi, Ist. Eccl., xviii., 63.
204 E. B. Pusey. The Councils of the Church, a.d. 51–381, p. 306. Tillemont, Mémoires, xvj., 662, who says,
“If none of those who die out of communion with Rome can merit the title of Saints and Confessors, Baronius
should have the names of St. Meletius, St. Elias of Jerusalem and St. Daniel the Stylite stricken from the Martyr-
ology.” Cf. F. W. Puller, The Primitive Saints and See of Rome, pp. 174 and 238. Many attempts have been made
to explain this fact away, but without success. Not only was the president of the Council a persona non grata to
the Pope, but the members of the Council were well aware of the fact, and much pleased that such was the case,
and Hefele acknowledges that the reason the council determined to continue the Meletian Schism was because
allowing Paulinus to succeed to Meletius would be “too great a concession to the Latins” (vol. III., p. 346).
Historical Introduction.
326
Historical Introduction.