(36) De Incarnatione et Contra Arianos
(ib. 984). The Athanasian authorship of this short tract is very
questionable. It is quoted as genuine by Theodoret Dial. ii. and
by Gelasius de duabus naturis. In some councils it is referred
to as ‘On the Trinity against Apollinarius;’ by Facundus as
‘On the Trinity.’ The tract is in no sense directed against
Apollinarius. In reality it is an argument, mainly from Scripture, for
the divinity of Christ, with a digression (13–19) on that of the
Holy Spirit. On the whole the evidence is against the favourable
verdict of Montfaucon, Ceillier, &c. That Athanasius should, at any
date possible for this tract, have referred to the Trinity as
‘the three Hypostases’ is out of the question (§10):
his explanation of Prov. viii.
22 in Orat. ii. 44
sqq. is in sharp contrast with its reference to the
Church in §6; at a time when the ideas of Apollinarius were in
the air and were combated by Athanasius (since 362) he would not have
used language savouring of that system (§§2, 3, 5, 7,
&c.). It has been thought that we have here one of the Apollinarian
tracts which were so industriously and successfully circulated under
celebrated names (infra, on No. 40); the express insistence on
two wills in Christ (§21), if not in favour of Athanasian
might seem decisive against Apollinarian authorship, but the peculiar
turn of the passage, which correlates the one will with σάρξ the other with πνεῦμα and θεός is not incompatible with the
latter, which is, moreover, supported by the constant insistance on God
having come, ἐν
σαρκὶ and ἐν
ὁμοιώματι
ἀνθρώπου. The ἄνθρωπος
τέλειος of §8 and the
ὡμοιώθη κατὰ
πάντα of §11 lose their edge in
the context of those passages. The first part of §7 could scarcely
have been written by an earnest opponent of Apollinarianism. This
evidence is not conclusive, but it is worth considering, and, at any
rate, leaves it very difficult to meet the strong negative case against
the genuineness of the Tract. (Best discussion of the latter in Bright,
Later Treatises of St. A., p. 143; he is supported by Card.
Newman in a private letter.)