AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK I.
459
tance. You would not say so much (for you
are not mad enough to openly fight against
God), yet this is your meaning in other
words, when you give man an attribute of
God, and make him to be without sin like
God Himself. Hence the Apostle, with his
voice of thunder, says, concerning different
graces : ' " There are diversities of gifts, but
the same spirit ; and differences of ministra-
tions, but the same Lord ; and there are di- versities of workings, but the same God, Who
worketh all things in all." 20. C. You push this one particular point
too far in seeking to convince me that a man cannot have all excellences at the same time.
As though God were guilty of envy, or un- able to bestow upon His image and likeness a
correspondence in all things to his Creator.
A. Is it I or you who go too far ? You
revive questions already settled, and do
not understand that likeness is one thing,
equality another ; that the former is a paint-
ing, the latter, reality. A real horse
courses over the plains; the painted one
with his chariot does not leave the wall.
The Arians do not allow to the Son of God
what you give to every man. Some do not
dare to confess the perfect humanity of
Christ, lest they should be compelled to ac- cept the belief that He had the sins of a man ;
as though the Creator were unequal to the
act of creating, and the title Son of Man were
co-extensive with the title Son of God. So
either set me something else to answer, or lay
aside pride and give glory to God.
C. You forget a former answer of yours,
and have been so busy forging your chain of
argument, and careering through the wide
fields of Scripture, like a horse that has
slipped its bridle, that you have not said a
single word about the main point. Your for-
getfulness is a pretext for escaping the neces-
sity of a reply. It was foolish in me to con- cede to you for the nonce what you asked,
and to suppose that you would voluntarily
give up what you had received, and would not
need a reminder to make you pay what you
owed.
A. If I mistake not, it was the question of
possible commands of which I deferred the
answer. Pray proceed as you think best. 21. C. The commands which God has
given are either possible or impossible. If
possible, it is in our power to do them, if we
choose. If impossible, we cannot be held guil-
ty for omitting duties which it is not given
us to fufil. Hence it results that, whether
Ciod has given possible or impossible com- mands, a man can be without sin if he chooses.
1 i Cor. xii. 4, 5.
A. I beg your patient attention, for what
we seek is not victory over an opponent, but
the triumph of truth over falsehood. God
has put within the power of mankind all
arts, for we see that a vast number of men
have mastered them. To pass over those
which the Greeks call 1 fiavavaoi, as we may say, the manual arts, I will instance grammar,
rhetoric, the three sorts of philosophy —
physics, ethics, logic — geometry also, and astronomy, astrology, arithmetic, music,
which are also parts of philosophy ; medi-
cine, too, in its threefold division — theory, in-
vestigation, practice ; a knowledge of law in
general and of particular enactments. Which
of us, however clever he may be, will be able
to understand them all, when the most elo-
quent of orators, discussing rhetoric and
jurisprudence, said : " A few may excel in one,
in both no one can." You see, then, that God has commanded what is possible, and
yet, that no one can by nature attain to what
is possible. Similarly he has given different
rules and various virtues, all of which we can-
not possess at the same time. Hence it hap-
pens that a virtue which in one person takes
the chief place, or is found in perfection, in
another is but partial ; and yet, he is not to
blame who has not all excellence, nor is he
condemned for lacking that which he has
not ; but he is justified through what he does
possess. The Apostle described the charac- ter of a bishop when he wrote to Timothy,
* " The bishop, therefore, must be without re- proach, the husband of one wife, temperate,
modest, orderly, given to hospitality, apt to
teach ; no brawler, no striker ; but gentle,
not contentious, no lover of money ; one
that ruleth well his own house, having his
children in subjection with all modesty."
And again, "Not a novice, lest, being puffed
up, he fall' into the condemnation of the devil. Moreover, he must have good testi- mony from them that are without, lest he fall
into reproach and the snare of the devil." Writing also to his disciple Titus, he briefly
points out what sort of bishops he ought to or-
dain : * " For this cause left I thee in Crete, that thou shouldest set in order the things
that were wanting, and appoint elders in
every city, as I gave thee charge ; if any man
is blameless, the husband of one wife,' having children that believe, who are not accused of
riot or unruly. For the bishop must be
blameless (or free from accusation, for so
much is conveyed by the original) as God's steward ; not self-willed, not soon angry, no
brawler, no striker, not greedy of filthy lucre ;
but given to hospitality, kind, modest, just,
1 That is, mean. 2 i Tim. iii. z sq. 3 Titus i. 5 s<i.