This
work, Against All the Heresies, is mentioned both by Eusebius
(πρὸς
ἁπ€σας τὰς
αἱρέσεις) Jerome (adv. omnes hæreses), but is not given in the
list on the statue. Quite a full account of it is given from personal
knowledge by Photius (Cod. 121), who calls it a small book
(βιβλιδ€ριον) directed against thirty-two heresies, beginning with the
Dositheans and ending with Noetus, and says that it purported to be an
abstract of lectures delivered by Irenæus. The work is no longer
extant (it must not be confounded with the Philosophumena, or
Refutatio, mentioned in note 1), but it has been in part
restored by Lipsius (in his Quellenkritik des Epiphanius) from
the anti-heretical works of Pseudo-Tertullian, Epiphanius, and
Philaster. There is in existence also a fragment of considerable
length, bearing in the ms. the title Homily
of Hippolytus against the Heresy of one Noetus. It is apparently
not a homily, but the conclusion of a treatise against a number of
heresies. It was suggested by Fabricius (who first published the
original Greek) that it constituted the closing chapter of the work
against the thirty-two heresies. The chief objection to this is that if
this fragment forms but one of thirty-two chapters, the entire work can
hardly have been called a “little book” by Photius. Lipsius
suggests that the little book of which Photius speaks was not the
complete work of Hippolytus, but only an abbreviated summary of its
contents, and this is quite possible. At any rate it seems probable, in
spite of the objections which have been urged by some critics, that
this constituted a part of the larger work, and hence we have one
chapter of that work preserved. The work seems to have been composed in
Rome and during the episcopate of Victor (as Lipsius holds), or, as is
more probable, in the early part of the episcopate of Zephyrinus (as is
maintained by Harnack). This conclusion is drawn from the dates of the
heretics mentioned in the work, some of whom were as late as Victor,
but none of them later than the early years of Zephyrinus. It must,
too, have been composed some years before the Philosophumena,
which (in the preface) refers to a work against heresies, written by
its author a “long time before” (π€λαι).
Upon this work and its relation to the lost Syntagma of Justin
Martyr, which Lipsius supposes it to have made use of, see his work
already referred to and also his Quellen der ältesten
Ketzergeschichte together with Harnack’s Quellenkritik der
Gesch. des Gnosticismus, and his article in the Zeitschrift
für historische Theologie, 1874, p. 143–226.