at the place where the knock is sounding? In this case also, therefore, we live beyond the
limits of our bodies. Or can we perceive by sense in a place in which we are not living? But
we know that sense cannot be in exercise where life is not.
6. The other three senses are exercised through immediate contact with their own organs.
Perhaps this may be reasonably disputed in regard to the sense of smell; but there is no
controversy as to the senses of taste and touch, that we perceive nowhere else than by contact
with our bodily organism the things which we taste and touch. Let these three senses,
therefore, be set aside from present consideration. The senses of sight and hearing present
to us a wonderful question, requiring us to explain either how the soul can perceive by these
senses in a place where it does not live, or how it can live in a place where it is not. For it is
not anywhere but in its own body, and yet it perceives by these senses in places beyond that
body. For in whatever place the soul sees anything, in that place it is exercising the faculty
of perception, because seeing is an act of perception; and in whatever place the soul hears
anything, in that place it is exercising the faculty of perception, because hearing is an act of
perception. Wherefore the soul is either living in that place where it sees or hears, and con-
sequently is itself in that place, or it exercises perception in a place where it is not living, or
it is living in a place and yet at the same moment is not there. All these things are astonishing;
not one of them can be stated without seeming absurdity; and we are speaking only of senses
which are mortal. What, then, is the soul itself which is beyond the bodily senses, that is to
say, which resides in the understanding whereby it considers these mysteries? For it is not
by means of the senses that it forms a judgment concerning the senses themselves. And do
we suppose that something incredible is told us regarding the omnipotence of God, when
it is affirmed that the Word of God, by whom all things were made, did so assume a body
from the Virgin, and manifest Himself with mortal senses, as neither to destroy His own
immortality, nor to change His eternity, nor to diminish His power, nor to relinquish the
government of the world, nor to withdraw from the bosom of the Father, that is, from the
secret place where He is with Him and in Him?
7. Understand the nature of the Word of God, by whom all things were made, to be
such that you cannot think of any part of the Word as passing, and, from being future, be-
coming past. He remains as He is, and He is everywhere in His entirety. He comes when
He is manifested, and departs when He is concealed. But whether concealed or manifested,
He is present with us as light is present to the eyes both of the seeing and of the blind; but
it is felt to be present by the man who sees, and absent by him who is blind. In like manner,
476
the sound of the voice is near alike to the hearing and to the deaf, but it makes its presence
known to the former and is hidden from the latter. But what is more wonderful than what
happens in connection with the sound of our voices and our words, a thing, for-sooth, which
passes away in a moment? For when we speak, there is no place for even the next syllable
till after the preceding one has ceased to sound; nevertheless, if one hearer be present, he
1024
To Volusianus