Cf. Irenæus, Adv. Hær. III. 23, where this
opinion of Tatian’s is refuted at considerable length. The
opinion seems a little peculiar, but was a not unnatural consequence of
Tatian’s strong dualism, and of his doctrine of a conditional
immortality for those who have been reunited with the Holy Spirit who
took his departure at the time of the fall (cf. especially his
Oratio, chap. 15). That Adam, who, by his fall, brought about
this separation, which has been of such direful consequence to the
race, should be saved, was naturally to Titian a very repugnant
thought. He seems, moreover, to have based his opinion, as Donaldson
remarks, upon exegetical grounds interpreting the passage in regard to
Adam (1 Cor. xv. 22) as meaning that Adam
is and remains the principle of death, and as such, of course, cannot
himself enjoy life (see Irenæus, ibid.). This is quite in
accord with the distinction between the psychical and physical man
which he draws in his Oratio. It is quite possible that he was
moved in part also by the same motive which led Marcion to deny the
salvation of Abraham and the other patriarchs (see Irenæus,
Adv. Hær. I. 27 and IV. 8), namely, the opposition between
the God of the Old Testament and the Christ of the New Testament, which
led him to assert that those who depended on the former were lost. We
learn from Clement (Strom. III. 12) and from Origen (de
Orat. chap. 24) that among Tatian’s heretical works was one
in which he discussed the early chapters of Genesis and perhaps it was
in this work that he developed his peculiar views’ in regard to
Adam.