with them. There is no one qualification of the mind whatsoever, that Christ has properly
made the term of this; not so much as a common belief that Jesus is the Messiah, or a belief
435
of the being of a God. It is the credible profession and visibility of these things, that is the
church’s rule in this case. Christian piety or godliness may be a qualification requisite to
communion in the christian sacraments, just in the same manner as a belief that Jesus is the
Messiah, and the Scriptures the word of God, are requisite qualifications; and in the same
manner as some kind of repentance is a qualification in one that has been suspended for
being grossly scandalous, in order to his coming again to the Lord’s supper; and yet godliness
itself not be properly the rule of the church’s proceeding, in like manner as such a belief and
repentance, as I have mentioned, are not their rule. It is a visibility to the eye of a christian
judgment, that is the rule of the church’s proceeding in each of these cases.–There are two
distinctions must be here observed. As,
1. We must distinguish between such qualifications as are requisite to give a person a
right to ecclesiastical privileges in foro ecclesiæ, or a right to be admitted by the church to
those privileges; and those qualifications that are a proper and good foundation for a man’s
own conduct in coming and offering himself as a candidate for immediate admission to
these privileges. There is a difference between these. Thus, for instance, a profession of the
belief of a future state and of revealed religion, and some other things that are internal and
out of sight, and a visibility of these things to the eye of a christian judgment, is all relating
to these things, that is requisite to give a man a right in foro ecclesiæ, or before the church;
but it is the real existence of these things, that is what lays a proper and good foundation for
his making this profession, and so demanding these privileges. None will suppose, that he
has good and proper ground for such a conduct, who does not believe another world, nor
believe the Bible to be the word of God. And then,
2. We must distinguish between that which nextly brings an obligation on a man’s
conscience to seek admission to a christian ordinance, and that which is a good foundation
for the dictate of an enlightened well-informed conscience, and so in properly a solid
foundation of a right in him to act thus. Certainly this distinction does really take place
among mankind in innumerable cases. The dictates of men’s consciences are what bring
them under a most immediate obligation to act; but it is that which is a good foundation
for such a dictate of an enlightened conscience, that alone is a solid foundation of a right in
him so to act. Believing the doctrine of the Trinity with all the heart, in some sense, (let us
suppose a moral sense,) is one thing requisite in order to a person’s having a solid foundation
of a right in him to go and demand baptism in the name of the Trinity; but his best judgment
or dictate of his conscience, concerning his believing this doctrine with this sincerity, or
with all his heart, may be sufficient to bring an obligation on his conscience. Again, when
a delinquent has been convicted of scandal, it is repentance in some respect sincere, (some
moral sincerity,) that is a proper foundation of a right in him to offer himself for forgiveness
1749
PART I. The Question stated and explained.