vii
Preface.
————————————
The work intrusted to me of preparing this volume evidently can be divided into two
separate parts. The first, the collecting of the material needed and the setting of it before
the reader in the English tongue; the other, the preparation of suitable introductions and
notes to the matter thus provided. Now in each of these departments two courses were
open to the editor: the one, to be original; the other, to be a copyist. I need hardly say that
of these the former offered many temptations. But I could not fail to recognize the fact that
such a course would greatly take from the real value of the work, and therefore without any
hesitation I have adopted the other alternative, and have endeavoured, so far as was at all
possible, to keep myself out of the question altogether; and as a general rule even the trans-
lation of the text (as distinguished from the notes) is not mine but that of some scholar of
well-established reputation.
In the carrying out of this method of procedure I have availed myself of all the transla-
tions which I could find, and where, after comparing them with the original, I have thought
them substantially accurate, I have adopted them and reproduced them. Where I have
thought that the translation was misleading, I have amended it from some other translation,
and, I think, in no case have I ventured a change of translation which rests upon my own
judgment alone. A very considerable portion, however, of the matter found in this volume
is now translated into English for the first time. For some of this I am indebted to my friends,
who have most kindly given me every assistance in their power, but even here no translation
has been made from the Greek without careful reference being had to the traditional under-
standing, as handed down in the Latin versions, and wherever the Latin and Greek texts
differ on material points the difference has been noted. I have not thought it necessary nor
desirable to specify the source of each particular translation, but I have provided for the use
of the reader a list of all the translations which I have used. I should also add that I have
not considered any one text sufficiently well established as to command any deference being
paid to it, and that I have usually followed (for my own convenience rather than for any
other reason) the text contained in Labbe and Cossart’s Concilia. No doubt Hardouin and
Mansi are in some respects superior, but old prejudices are very strong, and the reader will
remember that these differing Concilia gave rise to a hard-fought battle in the history of the
Gallican Church. I should add, however, that where more recent students of the subject
have detected errors of importance in Labbe’s text, I have corrected them, usually noting
the variety of reading. With regard then to the text I entirely disclaim any responsibility,
and the more so as on such a matter my opinion would be entirely valueless. And with regard
to the translation my responsibility goes no further than the certifying the reader that, to
all intents and purposes, the meaning of the original is presented to him in the English lan-
guage and without interpretation being introduced under the specious guise of translation.
Preface.
2
Preface.