But the order of things which is
above us, alike in the region of intelligence and in that of sense (if
by what we know we may form conjectures about those things also which
are above us), is itself established within the operation and power of
the Holy Spirit, every man receiving the benefit according to his own
desert and need. For although the arrangement and ordering of things
above our nature is obscure to our sense, yet one may more reasonably
infer, by the things which we know, that in them too the power of the
Spirit works, than that it is banished from the order existing in the
things above us. For he who asserts the latter view advances his
blasphemy in a naked and unseemly shape, without being able to support
his absurd opinion by any argument. But he who agrees that those things
which are above us are also ordered by the power of the Spirit with the
Father and the Son, makes his assertion on this point with the support
of clear evidence from his own life. For This
sentence and the passage following, down to the words “is wrought
by the Father and the Son,” are omitted in the editions of S.
Basil. as the nature of
man is compounded of body and soul, and the angelic nature has for its
portion life without a body, if the Holy Spirit worked only in the case
of bodies, and the soul were not capable of receiving the grace that
comes from Him, one might perhaps infer from this, if the intellectual
and incorporeal nature which is in us were above the power of the
Spirit, that the angelic life too was in no need of His grace. But if
the gift of the Holy Spirit is principally a grace of the soul, and the
constitution of the soul is linked by its intellectuality and
invisibility to the angelic life, what person who knows how to see a
consequence would not agree, that every intellectual nature is governed
by the ordering of the Holy Spirit? For since it is said “the
angels do alway behold the Face of My Father which is in heaven S. Matt. xviii. 10.,” and it is not possible to behold the
person of the Father otherwise than by fixing the sight upon it through
His image; and the image of the person of the Father is the
Only-begotten, and to Him again no man can draw near whose mind has not
been illumined by the Holy Spirit, what else is shown from this but
that the Holy Spirit is not separated from any operation which is
wrought by the Father and the Son? Thus the identity of operation in
Father, Son, and Holy Spirit shows plainly the undistinguishable
character of their substance. So that even if the name of Godhead does
indicate nature, the community of substance shows that this appellation
is properly applied also to the Holy Spirit. But I know not how these
makers-up of all sorts of arguments bring the appellation of Godhead to
be an indication of nature, as though they had not heard from the
Scripture that it is a matter of appointment Reading ὅτι
χειροτονητή, ᾗ φύσις
γίνεται.
The Paris Edit. and Migne’s S. Basil read ὅτι
χειροτονία ἡ
φύσις οὐ
γίνεται:
the Ben. S. Basil and Oehler read ὅτι
χειροτονητὴ
φύσις οὐ
γίνεται.
The point of the argument seems to be that “Godhead” is
spoken of in Scripture as being given by appointment, which excludes
the idea of its being indicative of “nature.” Gregory shows
that it is so spoken of; but he does not show that Scripture asserts
the distinction between nature and appointment, which the reading of
the Benedictine text and Oehler would require him to do.,
in which way nature does not arise. For Moses was appointed as a god of
the Egyptians, since He Who gave him the oracles, &c., spoke thus
to him, “I have given thee as a god to Pharaoh Ex. vii. 1..” Thus the force of the appellation is
the indication of some power, either of oversight or of operation. But
the Divine nature itself, as it is, remains unexpressed by all the
names that are conceived for it, as our doctrine declares. For in
learning that He is beneficent, and a judge, good, and just, and all
else of the same kind, we learn diversities of His operations, but we
are none the more able to learn by our knowledge of His operations the
nature of Him Who works. For when one gives a definition of any one of
these attributes, and of the nature to which the names are applied, he
will not give the same definition of both: and of things of which the
definition is different, the nature also is distinct. Indeed the
substance is one thing which no definition has been found to express,
and the significance of the names employed concerning it varies, as the
names are given from some operation or accident. Now the fact that
there is no distinction in the operations we learn from the community
of the attributes, but of the difference in respect of nature we find
no clear proof, the identity of operations indicating rather, as we
said, community of nature. If, then, Godhead is a name derived from
operation, as we say that the operation of the Father, and the Son, and
the Holy Spirit is one, so we say that the Godhead is one: or if,
according to the view of the majority, Godhead is indicative of nature,
since we cannot find any diversity in their nature, we not unreasonably
define the Holy Trinity to be of one Godhead The
treatise, as it appears in S. Basil’s works, ends
here..