(3) The Index to the Festal
Letters.—This chronicle, so constantly referred to throughout
this volume, is of uncertain date, but probably (upon internal
evidence) only ‘somewhat later’ (Hefele, E. Tr. vol.
ii. p. 50) than Athanasius himself. Its special value is in the points
where it agrees with the Hist. Aceph. (supr. Prolegg. ch.
v.), where we recognise the accredited reckoning of the Alexandrian
Church as represented by Cyril and Proterius (see Tillem. ubi
supr.). The writer undoubtedly makes occasional slips (cf.
Index iii. with Letter iv. and p. 512, note 1, Index
xiii. with Letter Some
phenomena might suggest (Hefele, ii. 88, note) that the Index
was originally prefixed to another collection of the letters, and was
copied by a collector or transcriber of our present corpus; cf.
Index xiii., note 17b, and p. 527, note 1. xiii.!), and the
text would be a miracle if it had come down to us uncorrupt (see notes
passim): but on the main dates he is consistent with himself,
with the Chron. Aceph. and (so far as they come in contact) with
the notices of the Alexandrian bishops above mentioned.