10. You, my brother, ask me to decide for you whether
men’s souls as made by the Creator come like their bodies by
generation from Adam, or whether like his soul they are made without
generation and separately for each individual. For in one way or the
other we both admit that they are God’s handiwork. Suffer me then
in turn to ask you a question. Can a soul derive original sin from a
source from which it is not itself derived? For unless we are to fall
into the detestable heresy of Pelagius, we must both of us allow that
all souls do derive original sin from Adam. And if you cannot answer my
question, pray give me leave to confess my ignorance alike of your
question and of my own. But if you already know what I ask, teach me
and then I will teach you what you wish to know. Pray do not be
displeased with me for taking this line, for though I have given you no
positive answer to your question, I have shewn you how you ought to put
it. When once you are clear about that, you may be quite positive where
you have been doubtful. i.e. you
may be quite sure that souls are created by God.