10. Nay, our most religious Emperor did at the
time prove, in a speech, that He was in being even according to His
divine generation which is before all ages, since even before He was
generated in energy, He was in virtue [Rather
‘potentially’ both here and three lines below.] Theognis,
[one] of the Nicene Arians, says the same, according to Philostorgius;
viz. “that God even before He begat the Son was a Father, as
having the power, δύναμις, of begetting.” Hist. ii. 15. Though Bull pronounces
such doctrine to be heretical, as of course it is, still he considers
that it expresses what otherwise stated may be orthodox, viz.
the doctrine that our Lord was called the Word from eternity, and the
Son upon His descent to create the worlds. And he acutely and
ingeniously interprets the Arian formula, “Before His generation
He was not,” to support this view. Another opportunity will occur
of giving an opinion upon this question; meanwhile, the parallel
on which the heretical doctrine is supported in the text is answered by
many writers, on the ground that Father and Son are words of nature,
but Creator, King, Saviour, are external, or what may be called
accidental to Him. Thus Athanasius observes, that Father actually
implies Son, but Creator only the power to create, as expressing
a δύναμις; “a maker is before his works, but he who says Father,
forthwith in Father implies the existence of the Son.”
Orat. iii. §6. vid. Cyril too, Dial. ii. p. 459.
Pseudo-Basil, contr. Eun. iv. 1. fin. On the other hand Origen
argues the reverse way, that since God is eternally a Father, therefore
eternally Creator also: “As one cannot be father without a son,
nor lord without possession, so neither can God be called All-powerful,
without subjects of His power;” de Princ. i. 2. n. 10.
hence he argued for the eternity of matter. with the Father
ingenerately, the Father being always Father, as King always, and
Saviour always, being all things in virtue, and being always in the
same respects and in the same way.