Against Apion, I. 8. The common
Christian tradition (since the first century, when it was stated in the
fourth book of Ezra xiv. 44 sq.) is that Ezra was the compiler of the
Old Testament canon. This, however, is a mistake, for the canon was
certainly not completed before the time of Judas Maccabæus.
Josephus is the earliest writer to give us a summary of the books of
the Old Testament; and he evidently gives not merely his own private
opinion but the commonly accepted canon of his day. He does not name
the separate books, but he tells us that they were twenty-two in number
(the number of the letters of the Hebrew alphabet), and gives us the
three divisions, so that we are able to ascertain his canon in detail.
It was doubtless as follows:—
1–5. Books of
Moses.
6. Joshua.
7. Judges and Ruth.
8. Samuel.
9. Kings.
10. Chronicles.
11. Ezra and
Nehemiah.
12. Esther.
13. Isaiah.
14. Jeremiah and
Lamentations.
15. Ezekiel.
16. Daniel.
17. Twelve Minor
Prophets.
18. Job.
19. Psalms.
20. Proverbs.
21. Ecclesiastes.
22. Song of Songs.
The earliest detailed list of
Old Testament books is that of Melito (given by Eusebius, IV. 26),
which is as follows:—
Books of Moses
Genesis.
Exodus.
Leviticus.
Numbers.
Deuteronomy.
Joshua Nave.
Judges.
Ruth.
Four of Kings.
Chronicles.
Psalms.
Proverbs.
Ecclesiastes.
Song of Songs.
Job.
Isaiah.
Jeremiah.
Twelve Minor
Prophets.
Daniel.
Ezekiel.
Ezra.
Melito says nothing of the
number twenty-two, and, in fact, his list, as he gives it, numbers only
twenty-one. His list really differs from Josephus’ only in
omitting the Book of Esther. This omission may be accidental, though it
is omitted by Athanasius and Gregory Nazianzen. He makes no mention of
Nehemiah, but that is doubtless included with Ezra, as in the case of
Josephus’ canon. His canon purports to be the Palestinian one,
and hence we should expect it to be the same as that of Josephus, which
makes it more probable that the omission of Esther was only accidental.
Origen (in Eusebius, VI. 25) tells us that there were twenty-two books
in the Hebrew canon; but his list differs somewhat from that of
Josephus. It is as follows:—
1–5. Books of
Moses.
6. Joshua.
7. Judges and Ruth.
8. Samuel.
9. Kings.
10. Chronicles.
11. Ezra I. and II.
12. Psalms.
13. Proverbs.
14. Ecclesiastes.
15. Song of Songs.
16. [Twelve Minor Prophets
(Rufinus).]
17. Isaiah.
18. Jeremiah, Lamentations, and
Epistle.
19. Daniel.
20. Ezekiel.
21. Job.
22. Esther.
“Besides these also the
Maccabees.”
The peculiar thing about the
list is the omission of the Twelve Minor Prophets and the insertion of
the Epistle of Jeremiah. The former were certainly looked upon by
Origen as sacred books, for he wrote a commentary upon them (according
to Eusebius, VI. 36). There is no conceivable reason for their
omission, and indeed they are needed to make up the number twenty-two.
We must conclude that the omission was simply an oversight on the part
of Eusebius or of some transcriber. Rufinus gives them as number
sixteen, as shown in the list, but the position there assigned to them
is not the ordinary one. We should expect to find them in connection
with the other prophets; but the various lists are by no means uniform
in the order of the books. On the other hand, the Greek Epistle of
Jeremiah (Baruch vi.) did not stand in the Hebrew canon, and can have
been included by Origen here only because he had been used to seeing it
in connection with Jeremiah in his copy of the LXX. (for in ancient
mss. of the LXX., which probably represent the
original arrangement, it is given not as a part of Baruch, but as an
appendix to Lamentations), and hence mentioned it in this book without
thinking of its absence from the Hebrew canon. Origen adds the
Maccabees to his list, but expressly excludes them from the twenty-two
books (see Bk. VI. chap. 25, note 5). Meanwhile the Talmud and the
Midrash divide the canon into twenty-four books, and this was probably
the original Jewish division. The number twenty-two was gained by
adding Ruth to Judges and Lamentations to Jeremiah. The number thus
obtained agreed with the number of letters in the alphabet, and was
therefore accepted as the number sanctioned by divine authority, and
the division was commonly adopted by the early Fathers. This is
Strack’s view, and seems better than the opposite opinion, which
is advocated by many, that the number twenty-two was the original. It
is easier to see how twenty-four might be changed to twenty-two than
how the reverse should happen. So, for instance, Jerome in his preface
to the translation of Samuel and Kings, makes the number twenty-two,
and gives a list which agrees with the canon of Josephus except in the
three general divisions, which are differently composed. It will be
seen that these various lists (with the exception of that of Origen,
which includes the Epistle of Jeremiah and appends the Maccabees)
include only the books of our canon. But the LXX. prints with the Old
Testament a number of Books which we call Apocrypha and exclude from
the canon. It has been commonly supposed, therefore, that there was a
regular Alexandrian canon differing from the Palestinian. But this is
not likely. An examination of Philo’s use of the Old Testament
shows us that his canon agreed with that of Josephus, comprising no
apocryphal books. It is probable in fact that the LXX. included in
their translation these other books which were held in high esteem,
without intending to deliver any utterance as to the extent of the
canon or to alter the common Jewish canon by declaring these a part of
it. But however that was, the use of the LXX., which was much wider
than that of the Hebrew, brought these books into general use, and thus
we see them gradually acquiring canonical authority and used as a part
of the canon by Augustine and later Fathers. Jerome was the only one in
the West to utter a protest against such use of them. Both Athanasius
and Cyril of Jerusalem added to the canon Baruch and the Epistle of
Jeremiah; but opinion in the Orient was mostly against making any books
not in the Hebrew canon of canonical authority, and from the fourth
century the Eastern Fathers used them less and less. They were,
however, officially recognized as a part of the canon by numerous
medieval and modern synods until 1839, when the larger Catechism of the
Orthodox Catholic Eastern Church, the most authoritative standard of
the Græco-Russian Church, expressly excluded them. The Latin
Church, meanwhile, has always regarded the Apocrypha as canonical, and
by its action at the Council of Trent has made them a part of the
official canon. See Strack’s article in Herzog, translated in
Schaff-Herzog; also Harman’s Introduction to the Holy
Scripture, p. 33 sqq. The subject is discussed in all Old Testament
introductions.