υἱοποιούμεθα
ἀληθῶς. This
strong term ‘truly’ or ‘verily’ seems taken
from such passages as speak of the ‘grace and truth’ of the
Gospel, John i. 12–17. Again S. Basil says,
that we are sons, κυρίως,
‘properly,’ and πρώτως ‘primarily,’ in opposition to τροπικῶς, ‘figuratively,’ contr. Eunom. ii. 23.
S. Cyril too says, that we are sons ‘naturally’
φυσικῶς as well as κατὰ
χάριν, vid. Suicer
Thesaur. v. υἱ&
231·ς. i. 3. Of these words,
ἀληθῶς,
φυσικῶς,
κυρίως,
and πρώτως, the
first two are commonly reserved for our Lord; e.g. τὸν
ἀληθῶς υἱ&
232·ν, Orat. ii.
§37. ἡμεῖς υἱοὶ,
οὐκ ὡς
ἐκεῖνος
φύσει καὶ
ἀληθεία,
iii. §19. Hilary seems to deny us the title of
‘proper’ sons; de Trin. xii. 15; but his
‘proprium’ is a translation of ἴδιον, not κυρίως. And when Justin says of Christ ὁ μόνος
λεγόμενος
κυρίως υἱ&
232·ς, Apol. ii. 6.
κυρίως
seems to be used in reference to the word κύριος, Lord, which he has just been using, κυριολογεῖν
being sometimes used by him as others in the sense of
‘naming as Lord,’ like θεολογεῖν. vid. Tryph. 56. There is a passage in
Justin’s ad Græc. 21. where he (or the writer) when
speaking of ἐγώ εἰμι ὁ
ὣν, uses the word in the same
ambiguous sense; οὐδὲν γὰρ
ὄνομα ἐπὶ
θεοῦ
κυριολογεῖσθαι
δυνατὸν,
21; as if κύριος, the
Lord, by which ‘I am’ is translated, were a sort of symbol
of that proper name of God which cannot be given. But to return; the
true doctrine then is, that, whereas there is a primary and secondary
sense in which the word Son is used, primary when it has its formal
meaning of continuation of nature, and secondary when it is used
nominally, or for an external resemblance to the first meaning, it is
applied to the regenerate, not in the secondary sense, but in the
primary. S. Basil and S. Gregory Nyssen consider Son to be ‘a
term of relationship according to nature’ (vid.
supr. §10, note 1.), also Basil in Psalm xxviii. 1. The
actual presence of the Holy Spirit in the regenerate in
substance (vid. Cyril, Dial. 7. p. 638.) constitutes this
relationship of nature; and hence after the words quoted from S. Cyril
in the beginning of the note, in which he says, that we are
sons, φυσικῶς, he proceeds, ‘naturally, because we are in Him, and
in Him alone.’ vid. Athan.’s words which follow in the text
at the end of §31. And hence Nyssen lays down, as a received
truth, that ‘to none does the term “proper,”
κυριώτατον, apply, but to one in whom the name responds with truth to
the nature,’ contr. Eunom. iii. p. 123. And he also
implies, p. 117, the intimate association of our sonship with
Christ’s, when he connects together regeneration with our
Lord’s eternal generation, neither being διὰ
πάθους, or, of
the will of the flesh. If it be asked, what the distinctive
words are which are incommunicably the Son’s, since so much is
man’s, it is obvious to answer, ἴδιος
υἱ& 232·ς and
μονογενὴς, which are in Scripture, and the symbols ‘of the
essence,’ and ‘one in essence,’ of the Council; and
this is the value of the Council’s phrases, that, while they
guard the Son’s divinity, they allow full scope, without risk of
entrenching on it, to the Catholic doctrine of the fulness of the
Christian privileges. vid. supr. §19, note.