Eusebius is the only Eastern writer of the early centuries to
mention Theophilus and his writings. Among the Latin Fathers,
Lactantius and Gennadius refer to his work, ad Autolycum; and
Jerome devotes chap. 25 of his de vir. ill. to him. Beyond this
there is no direct mention of Theophilus, or of his works, during the
early centuries (except that of Malalas, which will be referred to
below). Eusebius here calls Theophilus bishop of Antioch, and in chap.
20 makes him the sixth bishop, as does also Jerome in his de vir.
ill. chap. 25. But in his epistle, ad Algas. (Migne,
Ep. 121), Jerome calls him the seventh bishop of Antioch,
beginning his reckoning with the apostle Peter. Eusebius, in his
Chron., puts the accession of Theophilus into the ninth year of
Marcus Aurelius (169); and this may be at least approximately correct.
The accession of his successor Maximus is put into the seventeenth year
(177); but this date is at least four years too early, for his work,
ad Autolycum, quotes from a work in which the death of Marcus
Aurelius (who died in 180) was mentioned, and hence cannot have been
written before 181 or 182. We know that his successor, Maximus, became
bishop sometime between 189 and 192, and hence Theophilus died between
181 and that time. We have only Eusebius’ words (Jerome simply
repeats Eusebius’ statement) for the fact that Theophilus was
bishop of Antioch (his extant works do not mention the fact, nor do
those who quote from his writings), but there is no good ground for
doubting the truth of the report. We know nothing more about his
life.
In addition to the works
mentioned in this chapter, Jerome (de vir. ill.) refers to
Commentaries upon the Gospel and the book of Proverbs, in the following
words: Legi sub nomine ejus in Evangelium et in Proverbia Salomonis
Commentarios qui mihi cum superiorum voluminum elegantia et phrasi non
videntur congruere. The commentary upon the Gospel is referred to
by Jerome again in the preface to his own commentary on Matthew; and in
his epistle, ad Algasiam, he speaks of a harmony of the four
Gospels, by Theophilus (qui quatuor Evangelistarum in unum opus
dicta compingens), which may have been identical with the
commentary, or may have formed a basis for it. This commentary is
mentioned by none of the Fathers before or after Jerome; and Jerome
himself expresses doubts as to its genuineness, or at least he does not
think that its style compares with that of the other works ascribed to
Theophilus. Whether the commentary was genuine or not we have no means
of deciding, for it is no longer extant. There is in existence a Latin
commentary on the Gospels in four books, which bears the name of
Theophilus, and is published in Otto’s Corpus Apol. Vol.
VIII. p. 278–324. This was universally regarded as a spurious
work until Zahn, in 1883 (in his Forschungen zur Gesch. des N. T.
Canons, Theil II.) made an elaborate effort to prove it a genuine
work of Theophilus of Antioch. Harnack, however, in his Texte und
Unters. I. 4, p. 97–175, has shown conclusively that Zahn is
mistaken, and that the extant commentary is nothing better than a
Post-Nicene compilation from the works of various Latin Fathers. Zahn,
in his reply to Harnack (Forschungen, Theil III. Beilage 3),
still maintains that the Commentary is a genuine work of Theophilus,
with large interpolations, but there is no adequate ground for such a
theory; and it has found few, if any, supporters. We must conclude,
then, that if Theophilus did write such a commentary, it is no longer
extant.
The three books addressed to
Autolycus (a heathen friend otherwise unknown to us) are still extant
in three Mediæval mss. and have been
frequently published both in the original and in translation. The best
edition of the original is that of Otto (Corp. Apol. Vol.
VIII.); English translation by Dods, in the Ante-Nicene Fathers,
Vol. II. p. 85–121. The work is an apology, designed to exhibit
the falsehood of idolatry and the truth of Christianity. The author was
a learned writer, well acquainted with Greek philosophy; and his
literary style is of a high order. He acknowledges no good in the Greek
philosophers, except what they have taken from the Old Testament
writers. The genuineness of the work has been attacked, but without
sufficient reason.
From Book II. chap. 30
of his ad Autol. we learn that Theophilus had written also a
work On History. No such work is extant, nor is it mentioned by
Eusebius or any other Father. Malalas, however, cites a number of times
“The chronologist Theophilus,” and it is possible that he
used this lost historical work. It is possible, on the other hand, that
he refers to some other unknown Theophilus (see Harnack, Texte und
Unters. I. 1, p. 291).