Excursus on the XV. Anathemas Against Origen.
That Origen was condemned by name in the Eleventh Canon of this council there seems
no possible reason to doubt. I have given in connexion with that canon a full discussion of
the evidence upon which our present text rests. But there arises a further question, to wit,
Did the Fifth Synod examine the case of Origen and finally adopt the XV. Anathemas against
him which are usually found assigned to it? It would seem that with the evidence now in
our possession it would be the height of rashness to give a dogmatic answer to this question.
Scholars of the highest repute have taken, and do take to-day, the opposite sides of the case,
and each defends his own side with marked learning and ability. To my mind the chief
difficulty in supposing these anathematisms to have been adopted by the Fifth Ecumenical
is that nothing whatever is said about Origen in the call of the council, nor in any of the
letters written in connexion with it; all of which would seem unnatural had there been a
long discussion upon the matter, and had such an important dogmatic definition been ad-
opted as the XV. Anathemas, and yet on the other hand there is a vast amount of literature
subsequent in date to the council which distinctly attributes a detailed and careful examin-
ation of the teaching of Origen and a formal condemnation of him and of it to this council.
The XV. Anathemas as we now have them were discovered by Peter Lambeck, the Lib-
rarian of Vienna, in the XVIIth century; and bear, in the Vienna ms., the heading, “Canons,
of the 165 holy Fathers of the holy fifth Synod, held in Constantinople.” But despite this,
Walch (Ketzerhist., Vol. vii., p. 661 et seqq. and 671; Vol. viij., p. 281 et seqq.); Döllinger
(Church History, Eng. Trans., Vol. v., p. 203 et seqq.); Hefele (Hist. Councils, Vol. iv., p. 221
sq.), and many others look upon this caption as untrustworthy. Evagrius, the historian,
distinctly says that Origen was condemned with special anathemas at this Council, but his
evidence is likewise (and, as it seems to me, too peremptorily) set aside.
Cardinal Noris, in his Dissertatio Historica de Synodo Quinta, is of opinion that Origen
was twice condemned by the Fifth Synod; the first time by himself before the eight sessions
of which alone the acts remain, and again after those eight sessions, in connexion with two
of his chief followers, Didymus the Blind and the deacon Evagrius. The Jesuit, John
Garnier wrote in opposition to Noris; but his work, while exceedingly clever, is considered
by the learned to contain (as Hefele says) “many statements [which] are rash, arbitrary, and
inaccurate, and on the whole it is seen to be written in a spirit of opposition to Noris.”312
In defence of Noris’s main contention came forward the learned Ballerini brothers, of Ver-
ona. In their Defensio dissertationis Norisianæ de Syn. V. adv. diss. P. Garnerii, they expand
and amend Noris’s hypothesis. But after all is said the matter remains involved in the greatest
obscurity, and it is far easier to bring forward objections to the arguments in defence of
either view than to bring forward a theory which will satisfy all the conditions of the problem.
312 Hefele. Hist. Councils, Vol. IV., p. 230, note.
Excursus on the XV. Anathemas Against Origen.
574
Excursus on the XV. Anathemas Against Origen.