by Christ Himself, and maintained through the apostles and their successors in an unbroken
connection all over the world to the present day; or to a book which this Church condemns
as unknown, and which, moreover, is brought forward by men who prove their veracity by
praising Christ for falsehood.
3. Here you will say, Examine the genealogy as given in the two Gospels, and see if it
is consistent with itself. The answer to this has been given already.1009 Your difficulty is
how Joseph could have two fathers. But even if you could not have thought of the explana-
tion, that one was his own father, and the other adopted, you should not have been so ready
to put yourself in opposition to such high authority. Now that this explanation has been
given you, I call upon you to acknowledge the truth of the Gospel, and above all to cease
your mischievous and unreasonable attacks upon the truth.
4. Faustus most plausibly refers to what Jesus said of Himself. But how is this to be
known except from the narratives of His disciples? And if we do not believe them when
they tell us that Christ was born of a virgin, how shall we believe what they record as said
by Christ of Himself? For, as regards any writing professing to come immediately from
Christ Himself, if it were really His, how is it not read and acknowledged and regarded as
of supreme authority in the Church, which, beginning with Christ Himself, and continued
by His apostles, who were succeeded by the bishops, has been maintained and extended to
our own day, and in which is found the fulfillment of many former predictions, while those
concerning the last days are sure to be accomplished in the future? In regard to the appear-
ance of such a writing, it would require to be considered from what quarter it issued. Sup-
posing it to have issued from Christ Himself, those in immediate connection with Him
might very well have received it, and have transmitted it to others. In this case, the authority
of the writing would be fully established by the traditions of various communities, and of
their presidents, as I have already said. Who, then, is so infatuated as in our day to believe
that the Epistle of Christ issued by Manichæus is genuine, or to disbelieve Matthew’s narrative
of Christ’s words and actions? Or, if the question is of Matthew being the real author, who
would not, in this also, believe what he finds in the Church, which has a distinct history in
unbroken connection from the days of Matthew to the present time, rather than a Persian
interloper, who comes more than two hundred years after, and wishes us to believe his ac-
count of Christ’s words and actions rather than that of Matthew; whereas, even in the case
326
of the Apostle Paul, who was called from heaven after the Lord’s ascension, the Church
would not have believed him, had there not been apostles in life with whom he might
communicate, and compare his gospel with theirs, so as to be recognized as belonging to
the same society? When it was ascertained that Paul preached what the apostles preached,
and that he lived in fellowship and harmony with them, and when God’s testimony was
1009 III. 3.
555
Faustus recurs to the genealogy and insists upon examining it as regards…