“Let there be a word,” or, “Let speech be created,” or, “Let this or that have such or such an
appellation,” so, in advocacy of his trifling, he brings forward the fact that it was by the im-
pulse of the Divine will that Creation took place. For with all his study and experience in
the Scriptures he knows not even this, that the impulse of the mind is frequently spoken of
in Scripture as a voice. And for this we have the evidence of Moses himself, whose meaning
he frequently perverts, but whom on this point he simply ignores. For who is there, however
slightly acquainted with the holy volume, who does not know this, that the people of Israel
who had just escaped1125 from Egypt were suddenly affrighted in the wilderness by the
pursuit of the Egyptians, and when dangers encompassed them on all sides, and on one side
the sea cut off their passage as by a wall, while the enemy barred their flight in the rear, the
people coming together to the Prophet charged him with being the cause of their helpless
condition? And when he comforted them in their abject terror, and roused them to courage,
a voice came from God, addressing the Prophet by name, “Wherefore criest thou unto
Me?1126” And yet before this the narrative makes no mention of any utterance on the part
of Moses. But the thought which the Prophet had lifted up to God is called a cry, though
uttered in silence in the hidden thought of his heart. If, then, Moses cries, though without
speaking, as witnessed by Him Who hears, those “groanings which cannot be uttered1127,”
is it strange that the Prophet, knowing the Divine will, so far as it was lawful for him to tell
it and for us to hear it, revealed it by known and familiar words, describing God’s discourse
after human fashion, not indeed expressed in words, but signified by the effects themselves?
“In the beginning,” he says, “God created,” not the names of heaven and earth, but, “the
heaven and the earth1128.” And again, “God said, Let there be light,” not the name Light:
and having divided the light from the darkness, “God called,” he says, “the light Day, and
the darkness He called Night.”
On these passages it is probable that our opponents will take their stand. And I will
agree for them with what is said, and will myself take advantage of their positions1129 further
1125 ἀποδράντες. So also the Paris editt. The Munich ms. has ἀποδράσαντες, which form of the aorist is not
found at all in classic Greek, and is only used as Oehler notices by Epiphanius (e.g. Panar. liv. 1; lxviii. 4) and a
few other writers of a debased style.
1126 Exod. xiv. 15.
1127 Rom. viii. 26.
1128 Gen. i. 1, sqq.
1129 τὰ παρατέθεντα παρ᾽ ἐκείνων ἀνθυποίσω. He does this below. “And we will return to his argument that
even thence we may muster reinforcements for the Truth.” Gregory there goes on to show that Eunomius, who
attacks the doctrine that the names of God are the result of Conception, and makes their Scriptural use a proof
that they are God’s own direct teaching, himself seeks to overthrow this doctrine by means of the term Ungen-
erate, which is not in Scripture: hence, by his own showing, this theory about the Scripture names is not true.
The above is the reading of the Munich ms.: Oehler has the vox nihili παρεθέντα
524
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.