The
relationship of James and Jesus has always been a disputed matter.
Three theories have been advanced, and are all widely
represented.
The first is the
full-brother hypothesis, according to which the brothers and sisters of
Jesus were children of both Joseph and Mary. This was advocated
strongly by the heretic Helvidius in Rome in 380, and is widely
accepted in the Protestant Church. The only serious objection to it is
the committal of Mary to the care of John by Christ upon the cross. But
John was at any rate an own cousin of Jesus, and the objection loses
its weight when we realize the spiritual sympathy which existed between
Jesus and John, and the lack of belief exhibited by his own brothers.
The second is the half-brother hypothesis which regards the brethren
and sisters of Jesus as children of Joseph by a former wife. This has
the oldest tradition in its favor (though the tradition for none of the
theories is old or universal enough to be of great weight), the
apocryphal Gospel of James, chap. ix., recording that Joseph was
a widower and had children before marrying Mary. It is still the
established theory in the Greek Church. The greatest objection to it is
that if it be true, Christ as a younger son of Joseph, could not have
been regarded as the heir to the throne of David. That the objection is
absolutely fatal cannot be asserted for it is nowhere clearly stated
that he was the heir-apparent to the throne; it is said only that he
was of the line of David. Both of these theories agree in
distinguishing James, the brother of the Lord, from James, the son of
Alphæus, the apostle, and thus assume at least three Jameses in
the New Testament. Over against both of them is to be mentioned a
third, which assumes only two Jameses, regarding the brethren of the
Lord as his cousins, and identifying them with the sons of
Alphæus. This theory originated with Jerome in 383 a.d. with the confessedly dogmatic object of preserving
the virginity both of Mary and of Joseph in opposition to Helvidius.
Since his time it has been the established theory in the Latin Church,
and is advocated also by many Protestant scholars. The original and
common form of the theory makes Jesus and James maternal cousins:
finding only three women in John xix. 25, and regarding
Mary, the wife of Clopas, as the sister of the Virgin Mary. But this is
in itself improbable and rests upon poor exegesis. It is far better to
assume that four women are mentioned in this passage. A second form of
the cousin theory, which regards Jesus and James as paternal
cousins—making Alphæus (Clopas) the brother of
Joseph—originated with Lange. It is very ingenious, and urges in
its support the authority of Hegesippus, who, according to Eusebius
(H. E. III. 11), says that Clopas was the brother of Joseph and
the father of Simeon, which would make the latter the brother of James,
and thus just as truly the brother of the Lord as he. But Hegesippus
plainly thinks of James and of Simeon as standing in different
relations to Christ,—the former his brother, the latter his
cousin,—and therefore his testimony is against, rather than for
Lange’s hypothesis. The statement of Hegesippus, indeed,
expresses the cousinship of Christ with James the Little, the son of
Clopas (if Alphæus and Clopas be identified), but does not
identify this cousin with James the brother of the Lord. Eusebius also
is claimed by Lange as a witness to his theory, but his exegesis of the
passage to which he appeals is poor (see below, Bk. IV. chap. 22 note
4). Against both forms of the cousin theory may be urged the natural
meaning of the word ἀδελφός, and
also the statement of John vii. 5, “Neither
did his brethren believe in him,” which makes it impossible to
suppose that his brothers were apostles. From this fatal objection both
of the brother hypotheses are free, and either of them is possible, but
the former rests upon a more natural interpretation of the various
passages involved, and would perhaps have been universally accepted had
it not been for the dogmatic interest felt by the early Church in
preserving the virginity of Mary. Renan’s complicated theory (see
his Les Evangiles, p. 537 sqq.) does not help matters at all,
and need not be discussed here. There is much to be said, however, in
favor of the separation of Alphæus and Clopas, upon which he
insists and which involves the existence of four Jameses instead of
only three.
For a fuller discussion
of this whole subject, see Andrews (Life of our Lord, pp.
104–116), Schaff (Church Hist. I. 272–275), and
Weiss (Einleitung in das N. T. p. 388 sqq.), all of whom defend
the natural brother hypothesis; Lightfoot (Excursus upon “The
Brethren of the Lord” in his Commentary on Galatians, 2d
ed. p. 247–282), who is the strongest advocate of the
half-brother theory; Mill (The Accounts of our Lord’s Brethren
in the N. T. vindicated, Cambridge, 1843), who maintains the
maternal cousin theory; and Lange (in Herzog), who presents the
paternal cousin hypothesis. Compare finally Holtzmann’s article
in the Zeitschrift für Wiss. Theologie, 1880, p. 198
sqq.