ii. Early intercourse of Athanasius with Antony
(Prologue, and note 2). If the Benedictine text is correct, the
reference must be to the period before Athanasius became deacon to
Bishop Alexander, in fact to a period previous to 318 a.d. Tillemont (viii. 652), who maintains the other
reading, mainly relies upon the impossibility of finding room for the
intercourse in question in the early life of Athanasius. But his only
source of knowledge of that period is Rufinus, a very poor authority,
and Montfaucon replies with some force (Animadv. 11) that we
have no sufficient information as to how Athanasius passed the years
previous to his ordination by Alexander. He also suggests that
Athanasius may have been one of those who followed Antony’s
example (§46, cf. Apol. c. Ar. 6) after his first visit to
Alexandria. I may add that the notes to the Vita will call
attention to several points of contact between the teaching of Antony
and the earliest treatises of Athanasius. Yet the impression left on
the mind is here again one of uncertainty (cf. Prolegg. ch. ii. §1
fin.).