13. We know, beloved, that the bishop and all the clergy should be an example to the
people of all good works. And we are not ignorant how many have fallen or incurred suspi-
cion, through the women whom they have thus brought in. So that even if we should allow
that he commits no sinful act, yet he ought to avoid the suspicion which arises from such a
thing, lest he scandalize some one, or lead others to imitate him.
14. For how can he reprove or admonish another not to be too familiar with women,—lest
he fall, as it is written,2419—when he has himself sent one away already, and now has two
with him, blooming and beautiful, and takes them with him wherever he goes, and at the
same time lives in luxury and surfeiting?
15. Because of these things all mourn and lament by themselves; but they so fear his
tyranny and power, that they dare not accuse him.
16. But as we have said, while one might call the man to account for this conduct, if he
held the Catholic doctrine and was numbered with us,2420 since he has scorned the mystery
and struts about in the abominable heresy of Artemas2421 (for why should we not mention
his father?), we think it unnecessary to demand of him an explanation of these things.”
17. Afterwards, at the close of the epistle, they add these words:
“Therefore we have been compelled to excommunicate him, since he sets himself against
God, and refuses to obey; and to appoint in his place another bishop for the Catholic Church.
By divine direction, as we believe, we have appointed Domnus,2422 who is adorned with all
of the writers would lead them to paint the life of Paul as black as circumstances could possibly warrant, and
unfounded suspicions might therefore easily be taken as equivalent to proved charges.
2419 cf. Ecclesiasticus xxv.
2420 We get a glimpse here of the relative importance of orthodoxy and morality in the minds of these
Fathers. Had Paul been orthodox, they would have asked him to explain his course, and would have endeavored
to persuade him to reform his conduct; but since he was a heretic, it was not worth while. It is noticeable that
he is not condemned because he is immoral, but because he is heretical. The implication is that he might have
been even worse than he was in his morals and yet no decisive steps have been taken against him, had he not
deviated from the orthodox faith. The Fathers, in fact, by their letters, put themselves in a sad dilemma. Either
Paul was not as wicked as they try to make him out, or else they were shamefully indifferent to the moral char-
acter of their bishops, and even of the incumbents of their most prominent sees.
2421 On Artemas, or Artemon, see Bk. V. chap. 28, note 1. Paul’s heresy was a reproduction of his, as remarked
above, chap. 27, note 4.
2422 The action of this council in appointing Domnus was entirely irregular, as the choice of the bishop de-
volved upon the clergy and the people of the diocese. But the synod was afraid that Paul’s influence would be
great enough to secure his re-election, and hence they took this summary means of disposing of him. But it was
only after the accession of Aurelian that Paul was actually removed from his bishopric and Domnus was enabled
to enter upon his office (see chap. 27, note 4). The exact date of Domnus’ appointment is uncertain, as already
shown (see the note just referred to); so also the date of his death. Both versions of the Chron. put his accession
809
The Epistle of the Bishops against Paul.