43.4978 If Jupiter sought to have his games celebrated, and that afresh,4979 with greater
care; if he honestly sought to restore4980 the people to health, and that the evil which he had
caused should go no further and not be increased, would it not have been better that he
should come to the consul himself, to some one of the public priests, the pontifex maximus,
or to his own flamen Dialis, and in a vision reveal to him the defect in the games occasioned
by the dancer, and the cause of the sadness of the times? What reason had there been that
he should choose to announce his wishes and procure the satisfaction desired, a man accus-
tomed to live in the country, unknown from the obscurity of his name, not acquainted with
city matters, and perhaps not knowing what a dancer is? And if he indeed knew, as he must
have known if he was a diviner,4981 that this fellow would refuse to obey, would it not have
been more natural and befitting a god, to change the man’s mind, and constrain him to be
willing to obey, than to try more cruel methods, and vent his rage indiscriminately, without
any reason, as robbers do? For if the old rustic, not being quick in entering upon anything,
delayed in doing what was commanded, being kept back by stronger motives, of what had
his unhappy children been guilty, that Jupiter’s anger and indignation should be turned
upon them, and that they should pay for another’s offences by being robbed of their lives?
And can any man believe that he is a god who is so unjust, so impious, and who does not
observe even the laws of men, among whom it would be held a great crime to punish one
for another, and to avenge one man’s offences upon others?4982 But, I am told, he caused
536
the man himself to be seized by the cruel pestilence. Would it not then have been better,
nay rather, juster, if it seemed that this should be done, that dread of punishment should
be first excited by the father, who4983 had been the cause of such passion by4984 his disobedi-
ent delay, than to do violence to the children, and to consume and destroy innocent persons
to make him sorrowful?4985 What, pray, was the meaning of this fierceness, this cruelty,
which was so great that, his offspring being dead, it afterwards terrified the father by his
own danger! But if he had chosen to do this long before, that is, in the first place, not only
would not the innocent brothers have been cut off, but the indignant purpose of the deity
also would have been known. But certainly, it will be said, when he had done his duty by
announcing the vision, the disease immediately left him, and the man was forthwith restored
4978 40 in Orelli. The ms., 1st edd., and Ursinus want si.
4979 Lit., “and restored.” [Conf. Pont. Max. here named, with vol. iv. p. 74.]
4980 The ms. and Ursinus read reddere-t—“if he was to restore;” corrected, as above, by omission of t.
4981 i.e., if he is a god. Cf. iii. 20; [specially, note 3, p. 469].
4982 Lit., “the necks of.”
4983 Lit., “the terror of coercion should begin from the father with whom.”
4984 Lit., “even,” et.
4985 Lit., “to his grief.”
Chapter XLIII.
1310
Chapter XLIII.