Harnack evidently does
not fully appreciate the Catholic doctrine of the Sacrifice in the Holy
Eucharist. No catholic theologian teaches that the essence of
that sacrifice is to offer up the already present Body of Christ, but
that the essence of the Sacrifice is the act of consecration; the
“making the Eucharistic Sacrifice,” as he accurately says,
“whereby the common bread becomes the Bread of the
Eucharist.” Harnack says truly that “the sacrificial
act of the Christian here also is nothing else than an act of
prayer,” but he does not seem to know that this is the Catholic
doctrine to-day, nor to appreciate at its Catholic value the
“Prayer of Consecration.” The act of consecration is
the essence of the Christian Sacrifice according to the teaching of all
Catholics.