Chapter 5.—Concerning the More Secret Doctrine of the Pagans, and Concerning the
Physical Interpretations.
But let us hear their own physical interpretations by which they attempt to color, as
with the appearance of profounder doctrine, the baseness of most miserable error. Varro,
in the first place, commends these interpretations so strongly as to say, that the ancients
invented the images, badges, and adornments of the gods, in order that when those who
went to the mysteries should see them with their bodily eyes, they might with the eyes of
their mind see the soul of the world, and its parts, that is, the true gods; and also that the
meaning which was intended by those who made their images with the human form, seemed
to be this,—namely, that the mind of mortals, which is in a human body, is very like to the
immortal mind,264 just as vessels might be placed to represent the gods, as, for instance, a
wine-vessel might be placed in the temple of Liber, to signify wine, that which is contained
being signified by that which contains. Thus by an image which had the human form the
rational soul was signified, because the human form is the vessel, as it were, in which that
126
nature is wont to be contained which they attribute to God, or to the gods. These are the
mysteries of doctrine to which that most learned man penetrated in order that he might
bring them forth to the light. But, O thou most acute man, hast thou lost among those
mysteries that prudence which led thee to form the sober opinion, that those who first es-
tablished those images for the people took away fear from the citizens and added error, and
that the ancient Romans honored the gods more chastely without images? For it was through
consideration of them that thou wast emboldened to speak these things against the later
Romans. For if those most ancient Romans also had worshipped images, perhaps thou
wouldst have suppressed by the silence of fear all those sentiments (true sentiments, never-
theless) concerning the folly of setting up images, and wouldst have extolled more loftily,
and more loquaciously, those mysterious doctrines consisting of these vain and pernicious
fictions. Thy soul, so learned and so clever (and for this I grieve much for thee), could
never through these mysteries have reached its God; that is, the God by whom, not with
whom, it was made, of whom it is not a part, but a work,—that God who is not the soul of
all things, but who made every soul, and in whose light alone every soul is blessed, if it be
not ungrateful for His grace.
But the things which follow in this book will show what is the nature of these mysteries,
and what value is to be set upon them. Meanwhile, this most learned man confesses as his
opinion that the soul of the world and its parts are the true gods, from which we perceive
that his theology (to wit, that same natural theology to which he pays great regard) has been
able, in its completeness, to extend itself even to the nature of the rational soul. For in this
book (concerning the select gods) he says a very few things by anticipation concerning the
264 Cicero, Tusc. Quæst. v. 13.
Concerning the More Secret Doctrine of the Pagans, and Concerning the Physical Interpretations.
293
Concerning the More Secret Doctrine of the Pagans, and Concerning the Physical…